The Fox hit factory
Harry Warren was born Salvatore Guaragna, in 1893, in New York. The son of Italian immigrants, he grew up in Brooklyn. Mack Gordon, born Morris Gittler in 1904 in Grodno, in the Russian Empire, started out as a vaudeville singer and comedian. From 1940 on, the two men wrote together for 20th Century Fox.
The team turned out hit after hit. For Sun Valley Serenade, in 1941, they wrote Chattanooga Choo Choo, the first gold record in history, and At Last, which was finally launched the following year in Orchestra Wives. Warren would place 42 songs in the top 10 of the radio show Your Hit Parade, 21 of them at No. 1. He would win three Oscars, one of them with Gordon in 1943.
A film that angered Iceland
Iceland was meant to build on the success of Sun Valley Serenade. The studio brought back the same director, H. Bruce Humberstone, and the same lead couple: skater Sonja Henie and John Payne. The plot follows U.S. Marines stationed in Reykjavik, a direct echo of the American occupation of the island in 1941. It was one of the first musicals shot after the country entered the war.
Warren and Gordon delivered five songs. In the film, John Payne sings the ballad to Sonja Henie, and Joan Merrill performs it with Sammy Kaye's orchestra. The lyrics say there will be other loves, but none will replace this one. Film historian Tony Thomas, in his 1975 book on Harry Warren, called it "the song that shines from this film like a beacon."
The rest of the reception was less kind. Critics shrugged and audiences stayed indifferent. In Iceland, people were furious: the country saw itself portrayed as cold, stingy and servile. In September 1942, the daily Morgunblaðið denounced the film as absurd. The Icelandic government protested to Washington, and the film was retitled for its release abroad.
Just before the silence
Bands recorded the song in July 1942: Teddy Powell on the 17th, Woody Herman on the 24th, Tommy Tucker on the 31st. On August 1, the American musicians' union, led by James Petrillo, banned its members from all commercial recording sessions. The ban would last until 1943 at Decca, and until 1944 at Victor and Columbia.
Sales stayed modest. Woody Herman reached No. 23, Sammy Kaye No. 20 in early 1943. Then the song all but dropped off the radar.
Rebirth through jazz
It was jazz musicians who saved it. In January 1950, the Lionel Hampton Quintet recorded it for Decca. On guitar: Wes Montgomery. On November 28, 1952, Lester Young cut it with the Oscar Peterson Trio, featuring Barney Kessel. The following year, Art Tatum offered a version that keeps the introductory verse, rarely heard. In February 1954, Chet Baker sang it and played it on trumpet on Chet Baker Sings. The record took the song beyond the circle of jazz fans.
Why such success with musicians? The original key is E♭ major, and the form, A-B-A-C, has no real bridge: both halves start the same way. As early as bar 3, the harmony leaves the tonic to reach the minor sixth degree, through a half-diminished chord followed by a dominant. It's a minor II-V, which every guitarist runs into sooner or later. Clear changes, classic progressions: the ideal playground for improvising.
What you need to know to play it
The changes are in E♭ major, 32 bars (A B A C). After two bars of E♭maj7, the A section heads to the relative minor, C minor: Dm7♭5, G7, Cm7 form a minor ii-V-i, and Cm7 lasts two bars. Then B♭m7 and E♭7, the ii-V of A♭, set up the start of the B section: the tonic becomes E♭7, a dominant that pulls toward the fourth degree.
The B and C sections start the same way: A♭maj7, D♭7, then E♭maj7. D♭7, the flatted seventh degree, returns to the tonic "through the back door": all its notes come from E♭ minor, and its root moves up a whole step to E♭.
The B section continues with Cm7, then F7 for two bars (the dominant of the dominant), then Fm7 and B♭7, the ii-V that leads back to the A. The C section moves faster toward the end: C7, the dominant of Fm7, then Fm7, B♭7 and E♭6, and the last bar splits Fm7 and B♭7 to send the form around again.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the There Will Never Be Another You chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- E♭ major, and one note per dominant. The E♭ major scale covers E♭maj7, Dm7♭5, Cm7, A♭maj7, Fm7, B♭7 and E♭6. Elsewhere, change one note: B natural over G7, D♭ over B♭m7 and E♭7, A natural over F7, E natural over C7. Each time it's the chord's third, except over E♭7, where the D♭ is the seventh.
- The back door. Over D♭7, play E♭ natural minor (the notes of G♭ major). Aim for C♭, the seventh of D♭7, which moves down a half step to B♭, the fifth of E♭maj7; F, its third, moves up a whole step to G, the third of E♭maj7.
- The ii-V-i to C minor. The seventh of Dm7♭5 (C) moves down a half step to the third of G7 (B). Then the seventh of G7 (F) moves down a whole step to the third of Cm7 (E♭), and the B moves down a half step to B♭.
- The two bars of F7. In bars 5 and 6 of the B section, F7 lasts two bars before Fm7: only the third changes, A becomes A♭. Play the F7 arpeggio, then the Fm7 arpeggio in the same position, around the 8th fret (F on the A string).
The versions that matter
- Woody Herman and His Orchestra — Decca 78, recorded July 24, 1942: one of the recordings cut just before the musicians' strike, and a modest hit.
- Lionel Hampton Quintet — Decca 78, No. 27198, recorded in January 1950: the tune's comeback, with Wes Montgomery on guitar.
- Lester Young with the Oscar Peterson Trio — recorded in 1952, released on Norgran in 1954: the saxophonist's supple phrasing and Barney Kessel on guitar.
- Chet Baker — Chet Baker Sings (Pacific Jazz), 1954: the vocal version that made the song known far beyond jazz.
- Stan Getz Quartet — The Steamer (Verve), recorded in 1956, released in 1957: more than nine minutes of long-form improvisation over the changes.
Sources
- There Will Never Be Another You – Wikipedia — credits, the film Iceland, Joan Merrill and Sammy Kaye, Tony Thomas quotes (Harry Warren and the Hollywood Musical, Citadel Press, 1975, p. 191), July 1942 recordings (Powell, Herman, Tucker), Lester Young/Peterson, Art Tatum, Chet Baker, Stan Getz.
- There Will Never Be Another You – JazzStandards.com — Iceland designed to build on Sun Valley Serenade (same director, same actors), the film's reception, Herman/Kaye chart positions, oblivion then revival by Hampton in 1950, the verse in Tatum's version, Chet Baker's role, musical analysis (E♭, A–B1–A–B2, I–III7–vi, half-diminished chords).
- There Will Never Be Another You – Classic Jazz Standards — weak success at the time, chart positions and dates (Kaye, Herman), Wes Montgomery with Hampton (January 26, 1950), Barney Kessel with Lester Young, Chet Baker February 15, 1954, Getz November 24, 1956.
- Iceland (1942) – AFI Catalog — cast, director, plot (Marines in Reykjavik), five Warren and Gordon songs, planned as a "follow-up" to Sun Valley Serenade, retitled abroad after protests.
- Iceland (film) – Wikipedia — context of the 1941 American occupation, Icelandic protests, foreign titles (Katina, Marriage on Ice).
- Reykjavík Grapevine – the film Iceland and Iceland — how Icelanders were portrayed in the film, Morgunblaðið article of September 1942, the Icelandic government's complaint, title change.
- Harry Warren – Wikipedia — birth name, origins, Fox from 1940 with Gordon, Chattanooga Choo Choo as the first gold record, At Last, 42 songs in the Your Hit Parade top 10 including 21 No. 1s, three Oscars.
- Mack Gordon – Wikipedia — birth name, born in 1904 in Grodno, vaudeville beginnings, 1943 Oscar for You'll Never Know.
- 1942–1944 musicians' strike – Wikipedia — began August 1, 1942, James Petrillo, ended in 1943 for Decca and Capitol, in 1944 for Victor and Columbia.
- The Recording Ban of 1942 – University of Maryland Libraries — cross-check: August 1, 1942, Petrillo, ban on commercial sessions.
- Decca matrix 75755 – Discography of American Historical Recordings (UCSB) — Lionel Hampton Quintet, January 26, 1950, New York, Wes Montgomery on guitar, Decca 27198.
- Lester Young with the Oscar Peterson Trio – Wikipedia — session of November 28, 1952, Barney Kessel on guitar, released on Norgran in 1954.
- Chet Baker Sings – Wikipedia — session of February 15, 1954, Pacific Jazz, tune included on the original edition.
- The Steamer – Wikipedia — session of November 24, 1956, Verve, released 1957, running time 9:20.