A serenade in a haunted house
February 1944. Paramount released The Uninvited, known in France as La Falaise mystérieuse. It was Lewis Allen's first film as a director. In Cornwall, a brother and sister buy an abandoned house on the edge of a cliff. It's haunted. The brother, Rick Fitzgerald, played by Ray Milland, is a music critic and composer. He falls for Stella Meredith (Gail Russell), the granddaughter of the former owner, whose mother died in a fall from the cliff.
Rick writes her a serenade, which he calls To Stella by Starlight. The theme returns throughout the score, without words. It isn't a song yet: it's a piece for piano and orchestra, unabashedly romantic.
Victor Young, violinist turned studio man
Behind the theme stood a classically trained musician. Victor Young was born in Chicago at the very end of the 19th century. A violinist from childhood, he was sent to Warsaw to study at the conservatory, and as a teenager he played with the city's Philharmonic. Back in the United States, he worked his way through movie theater orchestras, arranging and radio. In the mid-1930s he settled in Hollywood and became one of Paramount's musical mainstays.
His style owed a lot to Rachmaninoff, and composer Miklós Rózsa placed him in the blend of romanticism and Broadway that made up the Hollywood sound of the day. Young piled up Oscar nominations, 22 in all, without ever winning in his lifetime. He died in November 1956. The Oscar came a few months later, posthumously, for Around the World in 80 Days.
Lyrics added after the fact
After the film, the theme went looking for a second life. Around 1946, Young handed it to lyricist Ned Washington, who had already won an Oscar for When You Wish Upon a Star. The title was imposed, and Washington managed to fit it in only once. It falls about three-quarters of the way through the song, not at the beginning or the end as custom would have it. The lyric is a dreamy declaration, from a lover who sees his beloved transfigured by the night.
In 1947, two records made it popular. Harry James and his orchestra recorded it as an instrumental and reached No. 21 in sales in May. Two months later, Frank Sinatra, with Axel Stordahl's orchestra, landed in exactly the same spot.
Jazz takes over the changes
On January 22, 1952, in New York, Charlie Parker recorded the first jazz version, backed by a large orchestra with strings conducted by Joe Lippman. Stan Getz followed in December. But it was Miles Davis who made the tune a lasting fixture. On May 26, 1958, he recorded it with the sextet that would soon make Kind of Blue, John Coltrane, Cannonball Adderley and Bill Evans included. He came back to it in the mid-1960s with his quintet, live at Philharmonic Hall in New York in 1964, then at the Plugged Nickel in Chicago in 1965, where the theme became a springboard for long improvisations.
Why the appeal? The form, first of all, is out of the ordinary: four eight-bar sections that don't repeat identically (it's often described as A B C A', with the last section picking up only the beginning of the first), rather than the usual AABA scheme. The tune doesn't open on the chord of its key, but on a half-diminished chord that delays the arrival home. It modulates along the way and piles up false resolutions. Critic Ted Gioia sees it as a masterpiece of misdirection. On top of that, a melody built on long notes leaves plenty of room for the player. For a guitarist, it's an excellent exercise in following changes that never stop moving.
What you need to know to play it
Stella by Starlight is in B♭ major, 32 bars in one continuous span, divided into four eight-bar sections (A, B, C, D). The changes move almost entirely by ii-Vs, and they take their time getting home: B♭maj7 doesn't show up until bar 9.
The A section starts far away, with Em7♭5 A7, a minor ii-V that doesn't resolve. Then come Cm7 F7, then Fm7 B♭7, a ii-V into E♭maj7, the IV chord, and A♭7, which leads to B♭maj7 through the back door. The B section finally resolves Em7♭5 A7 onto Dm7, then B♭m7 E♭7 slide toward Fmaj7. Em7♭5 A7 come back, and Am7♭5 D7 set up G7.
The C section holds each chord for two bars: G7, Cm7, A♭7, then B♭maj7. The D section steps down by whole steps with three ii-Vs built on m7♭5 chords, Em7♭5 A7, Dm7♭5 G7, Cm7♭5 F7, all the way to B♭maj7.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the Stella by Starlight chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- The minor ii-V Em7♭5 A7. It comes back four times, and D harmonic minor (with B♭ and C♯) covers it. Aim for C♯, the third of A7: at the start of the A section, it falls a half step to the C of Cm7; in the B section, it rises a half step to the D of Dm7.
- The three ii-Vs of the D section. Em7♭5 A7, Dm7♭5 G7, Cm7♭5 F7: the same progression, a whole step lower each time. Take an m7♭5 arpeggio shape followed by the third of the dominant (C♯, B, A), then shift the whole thing down two frets.
- The A♭7 that leads back to B♭maj7. Over A♭7, the D♭ major scale (A♭ Mixolydian). Aim for its seventh, G♭: it falls a half step to F, the fifth of B♭maj7. The move comes back at the end of the A section and in the second half of the C.
- The long bars of the C section. Over the two bars of G7, C harmonic minor (with B natural and A♭) announces Cm7: B, the third of G7, rises a half step to C. Over Cm7, the B♭ major scale.
The versions that matter
- Frank Sinatra — recording with Axel Stordahl's orchestra, 1947: the vocal version that took the tune onto the charts.
- Charlie Parker — Charlie Parker Big Band (Mercury), recorded in 1952: the first jazz reading, alto saxophone surrounded by strings; Art Ryerson plays guitar in the orchestra.
- Miles Davis — Jazz Track (Columbia), recorded in 1958: the Kind of Blue sextet, a gentle opening, then a confident swing.
- Miles Davis — My Funny Valentine (Columbia), recorded live in 1964: the quintet of Herbie Hancock, Ron Carter and Tony Williams, with George Coleman on tenor, stretches and reinvents the theme.
- Joe Pass — Virtuoso (Pablo), recorded in 1973: solo guitar; a reference for anyone who wants to play the changes as chord melody.
Sources
- Stella by Starlight — Wikipedia EN — origin in The Uninvited, the serenade scene, 1946 lyrics, Harry James and Sinatra chart positions (1947), Parker January 1952, Getz December 1952, Miles Davis 1958 and 1963-1965.
- Stella by Starlight — Wikipedia FR (in French) — the film's French title, title placed three-quarters of the way through, A1-B-C-A2 form, false resolutions, Miles' 1964 version, Joe Pass.
- Stella by Starlight — jazzstandards.com — film background, lyrics written to an imposed title, 1947 chart positions, first jazz versions, Miles 1958 and 1965, analysis by K. J. McElrath (form, half-diminished opening, stepwise melody and long notes), Rachmaninoff's influence and Miklós Rózsa's assessment.
- Stella by Starlight — classicjazzstandards.com — the film's New York release in February 1944, score sent to Washington in 1946, title in the middle of the lyric, dates of the James and Sinatra records.
- The Uninvited (1944 film) — Wikipedia EN — Lewis Allen, released February 1944, Paramount, characters and Cornwall plot.
- Victor Young — Wikipedia EN — born in Chicago (1899, with variants), studies in Warsaw, Warsaw Philharmonic, Hollywood in the mid-1930s, posthumous Oscar.
- Victor Young — tachna.com — Warsaw conservatory, Paramount, 22 nominations, posthumous Oscar for Around the World in 80 Days, died November 1956.
- Ned Washington — Wikipedia EN — Oscar for When You Wish Upon a Star.
- A 'Stella' For Springtime, Snowstorms Or Starlight — NPR — Ted Gioia's analysis (delayed tonic, surprise modulation), Miles at the Plugged Nickel in 1965.
- Harmony Series 4: The Uninvited and Stella — Hearing the Movies — the theme treated in several ways in the film, a piece conceived for piano in concerto style, song published in 1946.
- Verve Records Discography: 1952 — jazzdisco.org — Parker session of January 22, 1952, in New York, Joe Lippman's orchestra with strings, Art Ryerson on guitar, Mercury release and Charlie Parker Big Band LP.
- Jazz Track — Wikipedia EN — Stella recorded May 26, 1958, by the sextet, 1959 Columbia album.
- My Funny Valentine (Miles Davis album) — Wikipedia EN — February 12, 1964 concert at Philharmonic Hall, personnel, released 1965.
- My Funny Valentine — deaddisc.com — Stella by Starlight on the track list.
- Virtuoso (Joe Pass album) — Wikipedia EN — recorded August 28, 1973, Pablo, solo guitar, Stella on the program.
- Joe Pass — Virtuoso — Jazz Music Archives — cross-check of the track list and recording date.