A Broadway failure
November 1939. Jerome Kern is 54 and has nothing left to prove. With Oscar Hammerstein II he wrote "Show Boat" in 1927, which ran for 572 performances. Since 1937 he has lived in Hollywood, writing for the movies. But the team tries Broadway once more with "Very Warm for May."
The show opened on November 17, 1939, at the Alvin Theatre, on 52nd Street. The producer was Max Gordon. Vincente Minnelli handled the staging and the sets. The cast included Eve Arden, June Allyson and Vera-Ellen.
None of it helped. The plot, reworked at the last minute, left audiences cold. Reviews were mixed, and the house emptied fast. The curtain came down on January 6, 1940, after 59 performances. It would be Kern's last original show on Broadway. Only one song survived the wreck: All the Things You Are.
Too sophisticated a song?
Hammerstein's lyric is a simple, direct declaration of love: the beloved becomes the promise of everything beautiful in the world. The music is less simple than it sounds.
The song starts on an F minor chord, then travels through five keys: A♭, C, E♭, G and E. The chords move along the cycle of fourths, with a series of II-V-Is, the progressions that "lead back" to a tonic. The form is 36 bars long, not the 32 usual in songs of the time.
The most famous trick comes at the end of the bridge: you are in E major, far from where you started, and the changes have to get back to F minor. Kern relies on a note common to both worlds that simply changes its name (G♯ becomes A♭). For a guitarist it is the same fret on the neck: only your ear realizes you have changed worlds.
Several accounts report that Kern doubted such a broad audience would follow these detours. Critic Gary Giddins writes that Kern worried his penchant for these enharmonic changes would put listeners off. Records proved him wrong. Tommy Dorsey's orchestra, with Jack Leonard singing, took it to No. 1 in American record sales. Artie Shaw, with Helen Forrest on vocals, and Frankie Masters followed.
The boppers' playground
Jazz musicians quickly took hold of these changes. Pianist Art Tatum recorded it in 1940, and his version made a lasting impression on a young saxophonist named Charlie Parker. Coleman Hawkins and Erroll Garner cut it in 1944.
On February 28, 1945, Dizzy Gillespie and Charlie Parker went into the studio for the Guild label. That same day they recorded "Groovin' High" and "Dizzy Atmosphere." On guitar, Remo Palmieri backed the two horn players. With them, Kern's tune entered bebop history. A few months later, on November 11, 1945, Jerome Kern died in New York, with Hammerstein at his bedside.
In October 1947, Parker went further. With Miles Davis on trumpet, he recorded "Bird of Paradise" for the Dial label: a new melody laid over Kern's chords. That is called a contrafact. Giddins notes that the dramatic introduction Parker played became forever welded to Kern's changes. In his view, it was this record that settled the tune permanently in the jazz repertoire. In the Village Voice in 2000, the critic described those key changes as "turnback heaven" for jazz musicians. Other contrafacts would follow, by Kenny Dorham, Dexter Gordon and Charles Mingus.
Toronto, 1953
On May 15, 1953, five giants met at Massey Hall in Toronto: Gillespie, Parker, Bud Powell, Charles Mingus and Max Roach. The same night, a boxing match between Rocky Marciano and Jersey Joe Walcott kept part of the audience at home, and the hall was only half full. Parker played a plastic saxophone. The musicians were poorly paid, or not paid at all.
Yet the concert recording, released as "Jazz at Massey Hall," became legend. All the Things You Are is on it. It is also the last recorded meeting of Parker and Gillespie.
Since then the tune has never left the music stands. The reference site jazzstandards.com ranks it No. 2 among standards. Its strength lies in a solid melody and a demanding but logical chord progression, a road every improviser has to learn to travel one day.
What to know before you play it
All the Things You Are is the standard of modulations: in 36 bars it travels through five keys, A♭, C, E♭, G and E major, almost always by the cycle of fourths. That is what makes it an exercise improvisers both dread and love.
The first A starts on Fm7 and moves up in fourths (Fm7, B♭m7, E♭7, A♭maj7, D♭maj7) before a G7 pivots the changes toward C major. The second A takes exactly the same route, transposed a fourth lower, from Cm7 to E♭maj7 and then to G major. The bridge strings together two ii-V-Is, in G and then in E, and a C7 brings you back to the top. The last A restates the opening, then stretches to twelve bars: after D♭maj7 comes D♭m7 (the IV chord turned minor, very expressive), then a chromatic descent (Cm7, Bdim7, B♭m7) to the ii-V-I in A♭.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the All the Things You Are chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- Guide tones first. Thirds and sevenths only, in a single area of the neck (between the 3rd and 6th frets). On this tune, the seventh of one chord often falls a half step, sometimes a whole step, to the third of the next: you hear the modulations without having to think about keys.
- The ii-V-Is, one at a time. Isolate the ones in the bridge (Am7, D7, Gmaj7, then F♯m7♭5, B7, Emaj7) and work on them alone, on a loop, before putting them back into the changes.
- Four-note arpeggios, following the cycle of fourths: start each arpeggio on the note closest to the previous arpeggio.
- Slow down. This tune is often played fast; work on it at 80 to the quarter note, and go up by 10 once the changes stop surprising you.
The versions that matter
- Tommy Dorsey and His Orchestra (vocal: Jack Leonard) — 78 rpm record, 1939: the version that made the song a popular hit, No. 1 in U.S. sales.
- Dizzy Gillespie and Charlie Parker — Guild session of February 28, 1945, with Remo Palmieri on guitar: the tune's birth certificate in bebop, two years before "Bird of Paradise."
- Django Reinhardt and Stéphane Grappelli — recorded in Italy in 1949, released on the album "Djangology" (1961): Kern's changes meet Gypsy swing.
- The Quintet (Gillespie, Parker, Powell, Mingus, Roach) — "Jazz at Massey Hall" (Debut), Toronto, 1953: the concert version many consider the benchmark.
- Joe Pass — "Virtuoso" (Pablo), 1973: a model of solo guitar, with no accompaniment at all, on an entirely solo album.
- Keith Jarrett, Gary Peacock and Jack DeJohnette — "Standards, Vol. 1" (ECM), 1983: a nearly eight-minute trio reading that takes its time and lets the changes breathe.
Sources
- All the Things You Are — jazzstandards.com — dates and number of performances of "Very Warm for May," house empty by the second night, opinion attributed to Kern (song judged too complex), chart positions of the Dorsey (No. 1), Shaw (No. 8) and Masters (No. 14) records per Joel Whitburn, Tatum 1940 and his influence on Parker, Hawkins and Garner 1944, Giddins's view of "Bird of Paradise" (1947), key scheme, 36 bars, No. 2 in the site's ranking.
- All the Things You Are — Wikipedia — 1939 performers, 36-bar form, five keys, modulations unusual for the time, G♯ / A♭ enharmonic at the end of the bridge, contrafacts (Dorham, Gordon, Mingus), a strong melody and demanding but logical changes, Joe Pass (1973) and Keith Jarrett (1983) albums.
- All the Things You Are — Wikipedia (in French) — cross-check: 59 performances, surprise of Kern, who found the song too complex, Dorsey No. 1, Tatum/Parker, "Bird of Paradise," Massey Hall seen as the reference version, lyrics described as simple and direct.
- Very Warm for May — Wikipedia — Alvin Theatre, November 17, 1939, 59 performances, Max Gordon, Vincente Minnelli, plot reworked at the last minute, mixed reviews, the only song kept in the film "Broadway Rhythm" (1944).
- Very Warm for May — Playbill Vault — opening (11/17/1939) and closing (1/6/1940) dates, 59 performances, Max Gordon as producer, Minnelli as director and set designer, Eve Arden, June Allyson and Vera-Ellen in the cast.
- Jerome Kern — Wikipedia — birth (January 27, 1885), move to Hollywood in 1937, "Show Boat" (1927), "Very Warm for May" as Kern's last Broadway musical, death on November 11, 1945, with Hammerstein at his bedside.
- All the Things He Was — Gary Giddins, The Village Voice (2000) — Kern's worry that his enharmonic changes would put the public off, the phrase "turnback heaven," the tune's revival by Gillespie and Parker in 1945, the dramatic introduction associated with Parker, "Bird of Paradise."
- Charlie Parker Sessions, February 28, 1945 — Plosin (Parker discography) — date, Guild label, personnel (Clyde Hart, Remo Palmieri, Slam Stewart, Cozy Cole), titles recorded (Groovin' High, All the Things You Are, Dizzy Atmosphere).
- Groovin' High — Wikipedia — cross-check: Remo Palmier(i) on guitar on February 28, 1945.
- Charlie Parker's Savoy and Dial sessions — Wikipedia — "Bird of Paradise," October 28, 1947, New York, Dial, with Miles Davis, Duke Jordan, Tommy Potter and Max Roach; based on All the Things You Are.
- Jazz at Massey Hall — Wikipedia — May 15, 1953, Toronto, personnel, the tune on the record, the Marciano-Walcott fight, sparse audience, unpaid fees, last recorded meeting of Parker and Gillespie.
- The legendary jazz concert with Charlie Parker playing plastic sax has been reissued — NPR (Bill Brownlee, 2024, via LAist) — Massey Hall cross-check: half-full hall, boxing match, bounced checks; plastic Grafton saxophone.
- Djangology — Wikipedia — Reinhardt and Grappelli recordings made in Italy in 1949, released in 1961, All the Things You Are as track 9.
- Virtuoso (Joe Pass album) — Wikipedia — recorded August 28, 1973, Pablo, solo guitar, All the Things You Are on the program.
- Standards, Vol. 1 — Wikipedia — recorded January 1983, ECM, Jarrett-Peacock-DeJohnette trio, All the Things You Are as track 2 (7:47).