Pittsburgh, December 1938
In the late 1930s, Billy Strayhorn was in his early twenties. Born in Dayton, Ohio, in 1915, he was living in Pittsburgh. By day, he worked the counter at a drugstore and made deliveries. At night, he played and wrote music. In December 1938, a friend took him backstage at the Stanley Theatre, where Duke Ellington was performing.
Strayhorn sat down at the piano. He played "Sophisticated Lady" the way Ellington played it, then his own way. "Right there, the whole dynamic between the two of them was established," his biographer David Hajdu told NPR. Ellington invited him to join him in New York. Their partnership would last nearly thirty years, until Strayhorn's death in 1967.
Directions to Sugar Hill
The title started out as practical advice. According to the most widely told version, Ellington scribbled down directions to his home in Harlem for the young man, and those directions began with the subway line to take: the A train. Strayhorn turned them into a song.
The A was still new at the time. It had been running since September 1932 on the new Eighth Avenue line. It was the fastest way to Harlem and Sugar Hill, the well-to-do neighborhood where Harlem's elite lived, Ellington included. Strayhorn told a variant: you had to take the A rather than the D, which branched off before reaching Sugar Hill. Either way, the message was the same. Take the right train.
Saved from the trash
The tune owes its break to a copyright fight. From January 1 to October 29, 1941, the major American radio networks boycotted the catalog of ASCAP, the society that managed the rights of many songwriters. Ellington was a member: his own works could no longer be broadcast, at a time when radio aired a lot of live music.
He turned to two musicians who weren't tied to ASCAP: Strayhorn and his own son, Mercer Ellington. He needed new material, fast. Mercer said he found a score in a wastebasket that Strayhorn had thrown away. Strayhorn thought it sounded too much like the style of arranger Fletcher Henderson. It was Take the A Train.
Under the melody, Strayhorn slipped in the chord changes of a 1930 hit, "Exactly Like You," so well disguised that you can't recognize them. The form is classic: thirty-two bars, AABA.
Hollywood, February 15, 1941
On February 15, 1941, at RCA Victor's studios in Hollywood, the band cut the tune for records, a month after a first version recorded for radio. Ellington opens alone at the piano, for four bars. Then comes Ray Nance, hired in 1940 to replace trumpeter Cootie Williams. His solo, first muted, then open, fits the tune so well that countless trumpet players replay it note for note.
The record hit the sales charts in the summer of 1941. Take the A Train replaced "Sepia Panorama" as the band's theme song. It stayed that way until the Duke's death.
Lyrics and a trip around the world
Lyrics appeared as early as 1942, for the Delta Rhythm Boys. The ones that stuck were written in 1944 by Joya Sherrill, a young singer from Detroit. She showed them to Ellington, who hired her for his band. Those lyrics pick up the original idea: a subway ride to get to Harlem as fast as possible.
The song went on to travel the world. Willis Conover made it the theme of his jazz show on Voice of America, heard on every continent. In 1976, the 1941 recording entered the Grammy Hall of Fame. For a guitarist, it's a rite of passage: a melody that swings on its own, and a set of changes that teaches you how to move between chords.
What you need to know to play it
The changes are in C major, A A B A: thirty-two bars, four eight-bar sections, at a brisk swing. The A section sets up C6 for two bars, then D7♭5 for two bars: a seventh chord on the second degree (II7), with a flatted fifth. Its two notes outside C major, F♯ and A♭, give the tune all its color. D7♭5 then turns into Dm7: F♯ drops to F, and Dm7 G7 forms a ii-V that leads back to C6.
The first two A sections end with Dm7 G7 in bar 8, to kick off what follows; the last A stays on C6. The bridge moves to the fourth degree: Fmaj7 for four bars, then D7 for two (the second degree as a seventh chord again, this time with a perfect fifth), and Dm7 G7 lead back to the last A.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the Take the A Train chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- C major, except for two chords. The C major scale covers C6, Dm7, G7 and Fmaj7. The exceptions are D7♭5 and D7, which contain F♯.
- The whole-tone scale over D7♭5. D, E, F♯, G♯, A♯, C: it contains all four chord tones (the A♭ is spelled G♯ here). On a single string, it moves up two frets at a time.
- F♯ → F. When you go from D7♭5 (or D7) to Dm7, move F♯ down a half step: F is the third of Dm7. Then the seventh of Dm7 (C) moves down to B, the third of G7, and the seventh of G7 (F) moves down to E, the third of C6.
- The bridge in F. Over the four bars of Fmaj7, compare two colors: F major (with B♭) and the notes of C major (with B natural, the Lydian color). Over D7, add the F♯.
The versions that matter
- Duke Ellington and His Famous Orchestra — Victor 78, No. 27380, 1941: the original, with Ellington's piano intro and Ray Nance's trumpet solo, now canonical.
- Duke Ellington with Betty Roché — Ellington Uptown (Columbia), recorded in 1952: an eight-minute reworking, reorchestrated for Betty Roché's voice and Paul Gonsalves's tenor.
- Clifford Brown and Max Roach — Study in Brown (EmArcy), 1955: the hard bop quintet turns a big band theme song into a small-group playground.
- Ella Fitzgerald — Ella Fitzgerald Sings the Duke Ellington Song Book (Verve), 1957: with the Ellington Orchestra and Dizzy Gillespie as a guest on trumpet.
- Kenny Burrell — Ellington Is Forever (Fantasy), 1975: the guitar leading a large ensemble featuring Thad Jones, Joe Henderson and Jimmy Smith.
Sources
- Take the "A" Train — Wikipedia — 1939 sketch, Ellington's directions, ASCAP boycott, Strayhorn and Mercer affiliated with BMI, replacement of "Sepia Panorama," the wastebasket story, recordings of January 15 (transcription) and February 15, 1941, Nance's solo, Grammy Hall of Fame 1976, lyrics by Lee Gaines/Delta Rhythm Boys and by Joya Sherrill, Voice of America, versions.
- Take the "A" Train — French Wikipedia (in French) — cross-check: 1939, Joya Sherrill, the A-versus-D variant.
- Take the A Train — JazzStandards.com — context of the boycott, Mercer's account (via Stuart Nicholson), Strayhorn's account of the A and the D (via Stanley Dance), February 15, 1941 session in Hollywood (Victor 27380), piano intro, Nance's muted and open solo, chart entry in July 1941, versions.
- Take the A Train — NPR (NPR 100) — Strayhorn's youth in Pittsburgh, the 1938 meeting and "Sophisticated Lady," David Hajdu quote, the A as the fastest line to Harlem and Sugar Hill.
- Ellington & Strayhorn, Take the "A" Train — Smithsonian, National Museum of American History — Mercer's wastebasket story, harmonies of "Exactly Like You" (1930), theme song until Ellington's death, Willis Conover, 1952 reorchestration for Betty Roché and Paul Gonsalves, NPR 100.
- Billy Strayhorn — Wikipedia — born in Dayton in 1915, the December 1938 meeting in Pittsburgh, death in 1967.
- Billy Strayhorn at 100 — WFDD (public radio) — backstage at the Stanley Theatre in December 1938, directions written by Ellington, length of the partnership.
- Taking subway directions literally — All About Jazz — cross-check of the directions scribbled by Ellington and of the 1939 date.
- A (New York City Subway service) — Wikipedia — opening of the Eighth Avenue line on September 10, 1932, service to Harlem.
- ASCAP boycott — Wikipedia — dates of the boycott (January 1 - October 29, 1941) and its cause.
- Ray Nance — Wikipedia — hired in 1940 to replace Cootie Williams, solo on the first recording.
- Ellington Uptown — Wikipedia — recorded June 30, 1952, Betty Roché, running time 8:02, Columbia.
- Study in Brown — Wikipedia — dates (February 1955), EmArcy.
- Clifford Brown & Max Roach, Study in Brown — Verve Records — "Take The A Train" on the track list, quintet lineup.
- Ella Fitzgerald Sings the Duke Ellington Song Book — Wikipedia — Verve 1957, Dizzy Gillespie on "Take the A Train."
- Fantasy Records Discography 1975-1976 — jazzdisco.org — Kenny Burrell session of February 4-5, 1975, inclusion of the tune, lineup.