One night in 1926, a novel about Charleston
The story begins with insomnia. One night in 1926, George Gershwin was reading in bed: "Porgy," the novel DuBose Heyward had published the year before. The book follows a disabled beggar in the Black neighborhoods of Charleston, South Carolina. Gershwin wrote to the author right away: he wanted to make it an opera.
Heyward agreed. But Gershwin was busy on Broadway, and his commercial commitments pushed the project back about seven years. In the meantime Heyward and his wife, Dorothy, turned the novel into a play, "Porgy," a Broadway success in 1927. Work on the opera didn't really start until 1933. Ira Gershwin, George's brother, joined the team as co-lyricist in 1934.
A lullaby written before summer
Summertime was the first number Gershwin finished for the score. He started it in December 1933 and finished setting Heyward's poem in February 1934. So, contrary to a popular idea, he did not write it by the sea: according to Smithsonian Magazine, he worked on it in early 1934, back in New York, after two short trips to Charleston.
The lyrics are indeed Heyward's. It is a lullaby that a young mother, Clara, sings to her baby, promising peaceful days. The lyricist Stephen Sondheim considered Heyward's words for Summertime among the finest ever written for musical theater.
In the summer of 1934, Gershwin did settle near Charleston after all, on Folly Island, in a modest cottage where Heyward had an upright piano delivered. He complained about the heat and the mosquitoes, and even agreed to judge a local beauty contest. Above all, with Heyward, he visited the churches of neighboring James Island, home to a large Gullah population, and he listened. Orchestrating the opera then kept him busy from September 1934 to September 1935.
One question keeps coming up: does Summertime borrow from an existing song? Some hear an echo of the spiritual "Sometimes I Feel Like a Motherless Child." Gershwin, for his part, said he had used no pre-existing spirituals. He wanted to write his own.
1935: an opera that divides
Gershwin called his work a "folk opera" and insisted on a Black cast for the leading roles. Directed by Rouben Mamoulian, it tried out in Boston, at the Colonial Theatre, on September 30, 1935, before opening on Broadway at the Alvin Theatre on October 10. In the role of Clara, soprano Abbie Mitchell was the first to sing Summertime onstage. She was also the first to record it: a 1935 rehearsal recording captures her with Gershwin himself at the piano.
The critics were split. Composer and critic Virgil Thomson dismissed it as "crooked folklore and half-way opera," according to History.com. The show closed after 124 performances without earning back its costs.
Jazz claims the lullaby
The song, meanwhile, was already going its own way. On July 10, 1936, in New York, Billie Holiday recorded it with Bunny Berigan on trumpet, Artie Shaw on clarinet and Dick McDonough on guitar. She flattened the melody to suit her voice, which surprised listeners who knew the opera version. The record climbed to No. 12 on the American charts. Gershwin died on July 11, 1937, of a brain tumor. He would not see what came next.
On June 8, 1939, soprano saxophonist Sidney Bechet cut his version for a young label, Blue Note, with Teddy Bunn on guitar. The record became the company's first hit. Decades later it was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame.
Why do improvisers love it? The form is short, sixteen bars, and the chords move slowly. The melody rests on a pentatonic scale, the five-note scale every guitarist knows, and the whole thing evokes the blues. Bechet treated it almost like an extended blues. In short: lots of room to play, on familiar ground.
From modal jazz to psychedelic rock
The following decades brought one reinterpretation after another. Miles Davis and arranger Gil Evans recorded it in 1958 on their album devoted to the opera. John Coltrane stretched it past eleven minutes in 1960. In 1966 R&B singer Billy Stewart packed it with scat and reached No. 10 on the Billboard Hot 100. Two years later Janis Joplin and Big Brother and the Holding Company tipped it into rock.
For the Library of Congress, "Porgy and Bess" is the only American opera fully established in the international repertoire, and its lullaby has become a folk song in its own right. A lullaby that, nearly a century later, people still haven't finished singing.
What to know before you play it
Summertime is one of the easiest standards to start with: sixteen bars, one key, A minor, and a ballad tempo. The home chord is Am6, an A minor chord with a major sixth (F♯), a soft, slightly suspended color.
The A section alternates the tonic and its dominant (Am6, E7), moves to the iv chord (Dm7), then comes back through a minor ii-V (Bm7♭5, E7). The B section moves more: A7 pushes toward Dm7, then a series of two-beat chords (Dm7 G7, Cmaj7 F7, Bm7♭5 E7) leads back to A minor. It is an excellent first standard for learning to hear a dominant resolve.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the Summertime chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- A minor pentatonic. It works over almost the whole chart and gives you right away the bluesy color the tune has in so many versions.
- The E7 → Am resolution. Over E7, play G♯, the third of the chord, then move up a half step to A: that is the gesture that makes the resolution audible. The A harmonic minor scale (with its G♯) covers every E7.
- The Am6 arpeggio. A, C, E, F♯: four notes, and the last one gives the tune its color. Find them in one position, then one fret higher.
- The two-beat chords in the B section. For each chord, play only the note closest to the one you just played: you follow the harmony without racing.
The versions that matter
- Billie Holiday — Vocalion single, recorded July 10, 1936: the first jazz version on 78 to make a mark, showing you can make the melody your own instead of singing it as in the opera.
- Sidney Bechet — Blue Note single (BN 6), recorded June 8, 1939: a long soprano solo over Teddy Bunn's single-note guitar, the label's first hit and a Grammy Hall of Fame inductee.
- Ella Fitzgerald and Louis Armstrong — the album "Porgy and Bess" (Verve), recorded in 1957, released in 1959: two kindred voices, plus Armstrong's trumpet, over Russell Garcia's arrangements.
- Miles Davis — the album "Porgy and Bess" (Columbia), recorded in 1958, released in 1959: Davis's trumpet floats over an orchestral riff written by Gil Evans, in a version full of restraint.
- John Coltrane — the album "My Favorite Things" (Atlantic), recorded in October 1960, released in 1961: more than eleven minutes on tenor, with McCoy Tyner, Steve Davis and Elvin Jones, where the theme becomes a springboard for improvisation.
- Big Brother and the Holding Company (with Janis Joplin) — the album "Cheap Thrills" (Columbia), 1968: the lullaby goes rock, carried by Joplin's voice and by two guitars, Sam Andrew's and James Gurley's, answering each other.
Sources
- Summertime (George Gershwin song) — Wikipedia — composition dates (Dec. 1933–Feb. 1934), aim of writing an original spiritual, the role of Clara, Abbie Mitchell's recording, Billie Holiday's chart position (No. 12), Billy Stewart 1966, Bechet's Grammy Hall of Fame entry, pentatonic scale and kinship with the blues (K. J. McElrath), Sondheim's opinion, the "Motherless Child" question.
- Summertime — JazzStandards.com — first number completed (February 1934), about 20 months of work, premieres in Boston and New York, Abbie Mitchell as Clara, 124 performances, Holiday and Billy Stewart chart positions, Bechet and Blue Note, Miles Davis/Gil Evans, the song as lullaby and spiritual (Will Friedwald).
- Porgy and Bess — Wikipedia — Gershwin reads the novel in 1926, Folly Beach 1934, insistence on a Black cast, Colonial Theatre in Boston (Sept. 30, 1935), Alvin Theatre (Oct. 10, 1935), 124 performances, Mamoulian, "folk opera," Heyward as lyricist of Summertime.
- Porgy (novel) — Wikipedia — 1925 novel, subject (disabled beggar in the Black neighborhoods), 1927 play.
- Porgy and Bess — Library of Congress, American Treasures (UNT archive) — 1925 novel and 1927 play, orchestration from September 1934 to September 1935, the only American opera established in the international repertoire, Summertime as a folk song.
- Summertime for George Gershwin — Smithsonian Magazine — Summertime written in early 1934 in New York; stay on Folly Island from June 16, 1934, upright piano, heat and mosquitoes, beauty contest, Gullah churches on James Island.
- Gershwin on Folly — FollyBeach.com — arrival in mid-June 1934, beauty contest, James Island churches (cross-check of Smithsonian).
- Porgy and Bess premieres on Broadway — History.com — Gershwin's letter one night in 1926, roughly seven-year delay, Ira as co-lyricist in 1934, work from 1933 on, Virgil Thomson's quote, split critical reception.
- The first performance of Porgy and Bess — History Today — late-night reading of the novel in 1926, successful 1927 play, Black cast wanted by Gershwin, Mamoulian, 124 performances, show not profitable.
- George Gershwin, Porgy and Bess — Britannica — "American Folk Opera," mixed reception, Gershwin's death on July 11, 1937 (brain tumor).
- From a 1935 rehearsal — NPR — 1935 rehearsal recording: Abbie Mitchell, Gershwin at the piano.
- Abbie Mitchell — Wikipedia — role of Clara at the premiere, first to record Summertime.
- Summertime / Billie Holiday, matrix 19537 — Discography of American Historical Recordings (UC Santa Barbara) — date (July 10, 1936), location, Vocalion 3288, personnel (Berigan, Shaw, McDonough).
- The Dozens: Summertime — Jazz.com — Holiday's 78 as the first, and a shock for opera listeners, Bechet June 8, 1939, Ella and Louis 1957, Miles 1958, Coltrane October 1960.
- The Many Sounds of Summertime — Jazz History Online — Holiday flattens the melody, Bechet treats the 16-bar form as an extended blues, Teddy Bunn's guitar answers.
- 1939 June — Blue Note History — Bechet session of June 8, 1939, personnel, Blue Note 6, the label's first hit.
- New Editions To GRAMMY Hall Of Fame Announced — CBS New York — Bechet's Summertime (Blue Note, 1939) among the new inductees announced in December 2010.
- Porgy and Bess (Ella Fitzgerald and Louis Armstrong album) — Wikipedia — recorded in 1957, released April 1959 on Verve, Russell Garcia arrangements, Armstrong on trumpet on Summertime.
- Porgy and Bess (Miles Davis album) — Wikipedia — July-August 1958 sessions, released March 9, 1959, on Columbia, Gil Evans arrangements.
- My Favorite Things (John Coltrane album) — Wikipedia — recorded October 1960, released March 1961 on Atlantic, Summertime at 11:31, personnel.
- Cheap Thrills — Wikipedia — album released August 12, 1968, on Columbia, Summertime recorded in the studio, guitarists Sam Andrew and James Gurley.
- Interview: Sam Andrew on Janis Joplin — MusicRadar — the two intertwining, answering guitars on Summertime.
- Summertime Reaches 1000 Versions — SecondHandSongs — first song to reach 1,000 versions in the SHS database (post of February 22, 2014).
- The Surprising True Origins of Gershwin's Classic 'Summertime' — WFMT — debated kinship with "Motherless Child" (presented as speculative), Sondheim on Heyward's lyrics.