A Monday in March in a former church
On March 2, 1959, Miles Davis called his sextet into Columbia's 30th Street Studio in New York. The building was a converted former church that regulars simply called the Church. Around the trumpeter: John Coltrane on tenor saxophone, Cannonball Adderley on alto, Paul Chambers on bass, Jimmy Cobb on drums. On piano was Bill Evans, who had left the band a few months earlier and whom Davis had called back for the occasion.
Nobody had a full chart. Evans later said that nothing was written for this tune except the introduction line: for everything else, Davis gave his directions out loud. In his liner notes, the pianist even states that the leader had sketched these frameworks only hours before the session.
The legend of an album cut in a single pass doesn't hold up. The session tapes preserve several false starts and incomplete takes before the third, the keeper. On the very first attempt, producer Irving Townsend flagged a stray buzz coming from the snare drum. Davis chose to keep that rattle.
Two modes and a half step
The form is as classic as it gets: thirty-two bars cut into AABA, like so many American popular songs. The content is new. For sixteen bars, the soloists improvise on D Dorian. At the bridge, everything moves up a half step, to E♭ Dorian, for eight bars. Then back to D.
Where bebop raced through chord changes, Davis offered space. Soloists no longer chased a progression: they explored a color. That approach owes a lot to his exchanges with Bill Evans, who had studied with theorist George Russell.
Another bold move: Paul Chambers's bass states the theme. The piano answers with a two-chord figure, like an amen. Those chords stack three perfect fourths topped by a major third. Guitarists will recognize the layout: these are exactly the intervals of the five lowest open strings, from E to B. The voicing now bears the tune's name: the So What chord.
An introduction without a signature
Before the theme, piano and bass play a short introduction, out of tempo. The record credits Davis alone. But several people close to the session, including Jimmy Cobb and producer Teo Macero, recognized the hand of arranger Gil Evans, Davis's longtime collaborator. Cobb put it in one sentence, quoted by critic Richard Cook in his book It's About That Time: "Man, it sounds like Gil's stuff." Bill Evans, in a 1979 interview, mentions this written line without naming its author.
The theme's ancestry is debated too. Critic Stanley Crouch traced it to a "Pavanne" by Morton Gould, recorded in 1955 by Ahmad Jamal's trio. Historian Lewis Porter links that pavane instead to "Impressions," which John Coltrane would build a few years later on the same structure as "So What."
From television to the world's stages
A month after the session, on April 2, 1959, Davis played the tune for CBS cameras on The Robert Herridge Theater, a program he shared with Gil Evans's orchestra. Cannonball Adderley, suffering from a migraine, was missing, and Wynton Kelly was on piano. Davis took two solos to fill the gap.
Kind of Blue came out on August 17, 1959. A technical flaw dogged side A for years: one of the tape machines ran a little slow, and the records sounded slightly sharp. It took the reissues of the 1990s to restore the original pitch.
Onstage, the tune got faster year after year. By 1964, with Herbie Hancock, Ron Carter and Tony Williams, it had become a breakneck race. In 2002, Kind of Blue was added to the Library of Congress's National Recording Registry. It was certified five times platinum in the United States in 2019, and NPR calls it the best-selling jazz record of all time.
What to know before you play it
The changes come down to two chords. The form is 32 bars, A A B A, and each eight-bar section keeps the same chord from start to finish: Dm7 on the A sections, E♭m7 on the B. No ii-V, no resolution: these are modal changes, where you improvise on a mode rather than over chord progressions.
The A sections are in D Dorian: the notes of C major, played starting from D. What sets Dorian apart from natural minor is the major sixth, B natural. The B section moves everything up a half step, to E♭ Dorian (the notes of D♭ major), then the last A drops back down a half step to D.
That is where the whole challenge lies: sixteen bars of Dm7 in a row at the top of the form, eight of E♭m7, then eight of Dm7. With no chord changes to guide your phrases, it is up to you to build tension, count the bars and hear the half step of the B section coming.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the So What chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- D Dorian. Play the C major scale starting from D, and aim for F (the third of Dm7) and B (the sixth, the note that makes it Dorian).
- The half step in the B section. Shift the same fingering up one fret: you are now in E♭ Dorian. Play a phrase over Dm7, then play it again one fret higher when the B section arrives, aiming for G♭, the third of E♭m7.
- The chord in fourths. The five open strings from the sixth to the second give you E, A, D, G, B: three fourths and a third, all in D Dorian. That chord has no F, the third of Dm7: it colors the mode more than it states it. The same shape barred at the 10th fret (D, G, C, F, A) contains the third and sounds clearly like Dm7; moving between the two recreates the theme's "amen" answer. For the B section, move everything up one fret: barre at the 1st fret (F, B♭, E♭, A♭, C), then at the 11th fret (E♭, A♭, D♭, G♭, B♭) for E♭m7.
- The shifted pentatonic. Over Dm7, E minor pentatonic (E, G, A, B, D) uses only notes of D Dorian and gives a more open sound; over E♭m7, use F minor pentatonic. Leave space: eight bars on one chord don't need to be filled.
The versions that matter
- Miles Davis — Kind of Blue (Columbia), 1959: the founding version, medium tempo, rubato introduction and bass-piano dialogue.
- Miles Davis Quintet and Gil Evans Orchestra — The Sound of Miles Davis (CBS, filmed April 2, 1959): a rare filmed document, without Adderley, with Wynton Kelly on piano and Gil Evans's brass.
- Miles Davis — Four & More (Columbia), recorded in 1964: the new quintet turns the tune into a display of speed.
- George Benson — Beyond the Blue Horizon (CTI), 1971: the guitar opens the album with this tune, alongside Ron Carter and Jack DeJohnette, two Davis regulars.
- Ronny Jordan — The Antidote (Island), 1992: the English guitarist makes it an acid jazz classic, popularized by London DJs.
Sources
- So What (Miles Davis composition) — Wikipedia — date, AABA form, D and E♭ Dorian, bass stating the theme, intro attributed to Gil Evans, TV broadcast and Adderley's absence, faster live versions (Four & More), link with "Impressions," Stanley Crouch's "Pavanne" theory.
- Miles Davis: Kind of Blue — NPR — the best-selling jazz record of all time.
- Kind of Blue — Wikipedia — studio, two sessions, personnel, Evans's return, George Russell's influence, Evans's notes (frameworks sketched hours before), single-take legend, side A speed correction, release date, Library of Congress registry, 2019 RIAA certification.
- Kind of Blue — Wikipedia (in French) — cross-check of the sessions, the 16-8-8 structure, the single-take legend, the link with "Impressions," the certification.
- Miles Ahead — session of March 2, 1959 (plosin.com) — list of "So What" takes (false starts, complete take 3), snare buzz flagged by Townsend, slow tape machine and sharp records.
- Miles Ahead — session of April 2, 1959 (plosin.com) — CBS broadcast, Studio 61, personnel, Adderley's migraine, Davis's double solo, Gil Evans's orchestra, aired in 1960.
- Between Takes: The Kind Of Blue Sessions — NPR — Davis insists on keeping the snare rattle; dates of the two sessions.
- The Story Behind Kind of Blue: Interview with Bill Evans — Billboard Canada — nothing written for "So What" except the intro line, oral directions; Allan Chase on the intro written by Gil Evans, whom Evans doesn't mention.
- It's About That Time (excerpt) — OUPblog — Richard Cook: AABA form, piano-bass prelude, "amen" response, Cobb, Anita Evans and Macero attributing the prelude to Gil Evans, Cobb's quote.
- So What chord — Wikipedia — three perfect fourths and a major third, response figure played by Bill Evans.
- So What chord — Jazz-Guitar-Licks — same definition; match with the five lowest strings in standard tuning.
- Deep Dive with Lewis Porter: Impressions — WBGO — Morton Gould's "Pavanne" recorded by Jamal in 1955 and 1960; Porter links it to "Impressions," built on the form of "So What."
- Ahmad Jamal: Pavanne — Jazz.com — 1955 recording, origin in Gould's American Symphonette No. 2, claimed link with "So What."
- The Sound of Miles Davis — Open Culture — cross-check: April 2, 1959, Studio 61, Adderley's migraine, Davis's double solo, Gil Evans.
- When It Was New: Miles Davis's So What — AGNI — cross-check of the TV version (Kelly on piano, Adderley absent), tune not written out.
- Stuff of Legends: Miles and Co. and Kind of Blue — All About Jazz — studio in a former church (Cobb's recollection).
- Why Miles Davis's Kind of Blue is so great — Slate.fr (in French) — Evans's notes: 16-8-8 scheme and free rhythm of the introduction; George Russell's modal theory.
- CBS 30th Street Studio — Wikipedia — former church, nicknamed The Church.
- Four & More — Wikipedia — concert of February 12, 1964, released 1966, the concert's fast pieces.
- My Funny Valentine: Miles Davis in Concert — Wikipedia — personnel of the 1964 concert (Coleman, Hancock, Carter, Williams).
- Beyond the Blue Horizon — Wikipedia — February 1971, CTI, personnel, "So What" as the opener.
- Beyond the Blue Horizon was recorded 50 years ago — RTBF (in French) — cross-check of dates and personnel, Carter and DeJohnette close to Davis.
- George Benson on Miles Davis' So What — NEA — 1971 version.
- The Antidote (Ronny Jordan album) — Wikipedia — 1992, Island, "So What" as a single popularized by London DJs, acid jazz classic.
- Ronny Jordan dies aged 51 — Jazzwise — cross-check: The Antidote, 1992, Island, version of "So What."
- H.Res. 894 (111th Congress) — GovInfo — cross-check of the 2002 entry in the Library of Congress registry.