The quintet's composer
Wayne Shorter was born in Newark, New Jersey, in 1933. In 1959 he joined Art Blakey's Jazz Messengers, where he quickly became musical director and chief composer. In 1964 he joined Miles Davis' new quintet, alongside Herbie Hancock, Ron Carter and Tony Williams.
In that band, Shorter wasn't just the saxophonist. He was the one who wrote: on the album Miles Smiles, three of the six tunes would bear his name. At the same time, he was making a series of albums under his own name for Blue Note: Night Dreamer, JuJu, Speak No Evil.
February 24, 1966, Englewood Cliffs
On February 24, 1966, Shorter was at Rudy Van Gelder's studio in Englewood Cliffs to finish a new album produced by Alfred Lion. The quartet featured Herbie Hancock on piano, Reggie Workman on bass and Joe Chambers on drums. That day he recorded five tracks, including a new theme: Footprints.
The performance is dark and measured. The triple meter holds from start to finish, over a heavy, swaying piano figure that recalls John Coltrane's quartet. The album would be called Adam's Apple.
The record left in a drawer
Blue Note didn't release it right away. Adam's Apple didn't come out until October 1967, more than a year and a half after the session.
In the meantime, the tune had changed homes. On October 24 and 25, 1966, the Miles Davis Quintet recorded the album Miles Smiles at Columbia's 30th Street Studio in New York, with producer Teo Macero. Footprints was on it. The record came out on February 16, 1967. So it was through Miles, not its composer, that the wider public discovered the tune. That nearly ten-minute version made it a standard.
Herbie Hancock, for that matter, is the only musician besides Shorter who plays on both recordings.
A blues that doesn't sound like a blues
On paper, Footprints is a twelve-bar minor blues with six beats to the bar, in C minor, often written in 6/4 (the chart below breaks it into 3/4). For two-thirds of the form, the harmony barely moves. Then comes Shorter's signature: at the point where a minor blues usually takes a predictable path back to the opening chord, he doubles the speed of the changes and strings together altered chords. The return to the tonic seems to come from somewhere else.
With Miles, the tune becomes a rhythmic playground. Ron Carter keeps his bass line in three while Tony Williams moves from a four-beat swing to three-against-two polyrhythms. Around the 2:20 mark, the bass switches to four as well. The band plays along the border between triple and duple pulse, at the heart of rhythms of African origin.
For a guitarist, the lesson is twofold: a short chart, and a rhythm section worth listening to as closely as the chords.
Footprints everywhere
Miles' quintet took Footprints on tour. In the fall of 1967 the band crossed Europe, from Antwerp to Paris, where it played the Salle Pleyel on November 6. The box set released in 2011 gathers five of those concerts, and the tune appears in every one.
Shorter, for his part, never really left his theme behind. After the Weather Report years, the band he co-founded in 1970 with Joe Zawinul, he formed a quartet in 2000 with Danilo Pérez, John Patitucci and Brian Blade. Their album Footprints Live!, recorded at European festivals in the summer of 2001, came out in 2002.
Wayne Shorter died in Los Angeles on March 2, 2023, at 89. His footprints are still turning up: in 2020, the London band Ezra Collective reworked Footprints for a Blue Note compilation.
What you need to know to play it
The chart is in C minor and is written in 3/4: twenty-four bars, which match the twelve bars of a minor blues, each blues bar counting as two here. It's often felt in pairs of bars, in 6/4.
The skeleton is that of a minor blues: Cm7 (the i chord) for eight bars, Fm7 (the iv) for four, then Cm7 for four. Those sixteen bars are modal: long stretches on a single chord.
Everything changes in bars 17 to 20, one chord per bar: F♯m7♭5, B7, E7♯9, A7♯9. The roots move up in fourths (F♯, B, E, A): a ii-V toward E, then two chained dominants that ought to lead to D. But the chart drops back onto Cm7 for the last four bars. On Shorter's recording, B7 is replaced by F7(♯11), its tritone substitute: the bass then moves down in half steps, F♯, F, E. The move from A7♯9 to Cm7 holds together thanks to two notes: the sharp ninth of A7♯9 (B♯, which sounds as C) becomes the root of Cm7, and its seventh, G, stays put as the fifth.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the Footprints chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- C Dorian, then F Dorian. Over Cm7, the notes of B♭ major (C Dorian); over Fm7, those of E♭ major (F Dorian). Only one note changes: A becomes A♭.
- The C minor pentatonic. C, E♭, F, G, B♭: it works over Cm7 and Fm7, so over bars 1 to 16 and 21 to 24. It doesn't fit bars 17 to 20.
- The guide tones in bars 17 to 20. The seventh of each chord falls a half step to the third of the next: E (F♯m7♭5) to D♯ (B7), A (B7) to G♯ (E7♯9), D (E7♯9) to C♯ (A7♯9). Then C♯ falls a half step to C, the root of Cm7.
- Count the 3/4 in pairs. Count from one to six over each pair of bars: that's how the chart breathes. Play it first in sustained chords, one chord per pair of bars on the modal stretches and one per bar in bars 17 to 20, before you improvise.
The versions that matter
- Wayne Shorter — Adam's Apple (Blue Note), recorded in 1966, released in 1967: the original version, in quartet with Herbie Hancock, Reggie Workman and Joe Chambers.
- Miles Davis Quintet — Miles Smiles (Columbia), 1967: the version that made the theme a standard, with the rhythmic interplay of Tony Williams and Ron Carter.
- Miles Davis Quintet — Live in Europe 1967: The Bootleg Series Vol. 1 (Columbia/Legacy), released in 2011: five live versions, including the one from the Salle Pleyel in Paris on November 6, 1967.
- Pat Martino — The Visit (Cobblestone), recorded in 1972, reissued as Footprints: a slow reading for two guitars, with Bobby Rose, Richard Davis and Billy Higgins.
- Wayne Shorter — Footprints Live! (Verve), 2002: the composer revisits his theme with his 2000s quartet.
- Ezra Collective — Blue Note Re:imagined (Blue Note/Decca), 2020: London's young jazz scene takes on the tune.
Sources
- Footprints (composition) — Wikipedia (EN) — first version on Adam's Apple, Miles Smiles released before Adam's Apple, minor blues in C, doubled harmonic rhythm in the turnaround (F♯m9♭5, F7♯11, E, A7♯9 on Shorter's version), written in 3/4 or 6/8, triple/duple interplay, bass switch at 2:20
- Adam's Apple (album) — Wikipedia (EN) — sessions of February 3 and 24, 1966, Van Gelder, Alfred Lion, personnel, released October 1967
- Miles Smiles — Wikipedia (EN) — sessions of October 24-25, 1966, Columbia 30th Street, Teo Macero, released February 16, 1967, length of Footprints, rhythmic interplay
- Wayne Shorter — Wikipedia (EN) — born in Newark in 1933, Jazz Messengers (musical director), joined Miles in 1964, Blue Note albums, Weather Report, 2000 quartet, died March 2, 2023
- Footprints — Jazz on the Tube — cross-check: February 24, 1966, personnel, Miles' version as the one that made it a standard, Shorter with Miles for more than a year
- BLP 4232 Adam's Apple — BLP1553 blog — cross-check of dates and personnel; notes by Bob Blumenthal (steady triple meter, Coltrane-style pendulum-like piano) and Don Heckman
- Wayne Shorter "Footprints" — Jazzomat Research Project (HfM Weimar) — C minor, 6/4, 12-bar chorus, chords of bars 9-10
- Jazzdisco — Miles Davis, session index — sessions of October 24 and 25, 1966, at Columbia 30th Street, dates of the 1967 European tour including Paris on November 6
- Live in Europe 1967: The Bootleg Series Vol. 1 — Wikipedia (EN) — released in 2011, five versions of Footprints including the Salle Pleyel
- Footprints Live! — Wikipedia (EN) — recordings from July 2001 (Vitoria, Marseille, Perugia), Verve, 2002, personnel
- The Visit (Pat Martino album) — Wikipedia (EN) — March 24, 1972, Cobblestone, Footprints as track 4, personnel, reissued as Footprints
- Pat Martino: Footprints — JazzTimes — cross-check of the reissue and personnel, slow interpretation
- Blue Note Re:imagined — bluenote.com — Ezra Collective, Footprints, released 2020, Blue Note and Decca
- Ezra Collective give Wayne Shorter's Footprints a fresh twist — Dork — cross-check of Ezra Collective's cover (June 2020)