July 1951, WOR Studios
In the early 1940s, Thelonious Monk was the house pianist at Minton's Playhouse, in Harlem. In that club, after hours, a good part of bebop was being invented. In 1947, Monk began recording under his own name for Blue Note, Alfred Lion's label. The sessions were few and far between.
On July 23, 1951, he went into WOR Studios in New York with a quintet: Sahib Shihab on alto sax, Milt Jackson on vibraphone, Al McKibbon on bass, Art Blakey on drums. That day, he cut several pieces from his book, including "Four in One" and "Ask Me Now." And a blues: Straight, No Chaser.
The record opens with a drum chorus by Blakey. Monk then states the melody and takes the first solo, before Shihab and Jackson. The tune first came out as a 78, then on volume 2 of "Genius of Modern Music," a 10-inch LP released by Blue Note in 1952.
A blues that turns in on itself
The title comes from bar talk. A "straight" drink is served neat, with no water or ice. The "chaser" is the glass you drink right after to soften the blow. Here, there's no chaser: the blues is served neat.
The changes, for their part, are a twelve-bar blues as classic as they come. All the originality is in the melody. Monk spins a single small idea, which he places at different spots in the bar and ends differently each time. Your ear thinks it has the motif pinned down, then it lands somewhere else. The result sounds simple and turns out to be fiendishly hard to learn.
Six years out of the clubs
A few weeks later, in August 1951, police searched a car parked near Monk's home. Inside were Monk, his friend the pianist Bud Powell, and other passengers. The officers found heroin. Monk spent sixty days in jail.
The heaviest penalty was elsewhere. He lost his "cabaret card," the permit New York required to play in venues that served alcohol. He wouldn't get it back until 1957. A stubborn legend has it that he took the fall for Powell by refusing to give him up. Recent research casts serious doubt on that story. One fact remains: for nearly six years, one of jazz's major composers was kept out of his own city's clubs. He kept recording and playing anyway, in Brooklyn venues or in concert.
1957-1958: the comeback, then Miles
In 1957, Monk returned to the spotlight. In June, he settled in for six months at the Five Spot, in New York, with John Coltrane on tenor. In August, he recorded Straight, No Chaser again with baritone saxophonist Gerry Mulligan, for the Riverside label.
On February 4, 1958, it was Miles Davis's turn. His sextet, with Cannonball Adderley, John Coltrane, Red Garland, Paul Chambers and Philly Joe Jones, recorded it for the album "Milestones." That version, with Coltrane's double-time solo, did a lot to establish the tune as a must-know.
From Columbia to the screen
In 1962, Monk signed with Columbia. There he gave the tune a new life with his quartet: Charlie Rouse on tenor, Larry Gales on bass, Ben Riley on drums. Produced by Teo Macero, the album released in 1967 is even named after the blues: "Straight, No Chaser." The track runs more than ten minutes.
Monk died on February 17, 1982. Six years later, the title resurfaced in movie theaters. In 1988 came "Thelonious Monk: Straight, No Chaser," a documentary by Charlotte Zwerin, with Clint Eastwood as executive producer. It draws on footage shot in 1967 by Christian and Michael Blackwood for West German television. You see the pianist at work, and the fragility of the man. In 2017, the film was added to the U.S. National Film Registry.
What you need to know to play it
It's a twelve-bar blues in F, in its bebop version, in 4/4 at a brisk tempo. The skeleton is the blues: F7 (I), B♭7 (IV) as early as bar 2, then back to F7. Bar 4 adds a ii-V to the IV, Cm7 F7, which pushes toward B♭7 in bar 5.
In bar 6, Bdim7 replaces the second B♭7: the bass moves up a half step, from B♭ to B, before going back to F7. The ending chains ii-Vs: Am7 D7, in bar 8, pushes toward Gm7; Gm7 then C7 (bars 9 and 10) lead back to F7. The last two bars, F7 D7 then Gm7 C7, form a I-VI-ii-V turnaround with two beats per chord, which sends the form around again.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the Straight, No Chaser chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- The F blues scale. F, A♭, B♭, B, C, E♭: it works over the whole form and gives you the tune's character right away.
- Two half steps from F7 to B♭7. The seventh of F7 (E♭) moves down to D, the third of B♭7; the third of F7 (A) moves down to A♭, the seventh of B♭7.
- Just one note changes. B♭7 (B♭, D, F, A♭) and Bdim7 (B, D, F, A♭) differ by a single note. Keep D, F and A♭ in your phrases and bring out the B.
- The ii-Vs at the end. String together the arpeggios of Am7, D7, Gm7 and C7 in a single area of the neck. Guide tones: G (seventh of Am7) moves down to F♯ (third of D7), F (seventh of Gm7) to E (third of C7), B♭ (seventh of C7) to A (third of F7).
The versions that matter
- Thelonious Monk Quintet — Genius of Modern Music, Vol. 2 (Blue Note), recorded in 1951, released in 1952: the original, opened by Art Blakey's drums, with Milt Jackson on vibraphone.
- Gerry Mulligan and Thelonious Monk — Mulligan Meets Monk (Riverside), 1957: Mulligan's fluid baritone against Monk's angles, with Wilbur Ware and Shadow Wilson.
- Miles Davis — Milestones (Columbia), 1958: the version that made the tune a classic, with Coltrane and Cannonball Adderley.
- Thelonious Monk — 5 by Monk by 5 (Riverside), 1959: a quintet with Thad Jones on cornet and Charlie Rouse, at a markedly slower tempo.
- Thelonious Monk — Straight, No Chaser (Columbia), 1967: the mature quartet's reading, with long solos by Monk and Rouse.
Sources
- Straight No Chaser — JazzStandards.com — session of July 23, 1951 and lineup, running order (Blakey's chorus, Monk, Shihab, Jackson), structure of the melody (one idea moved around the bar, per Mark C. Gridley), Miles Davis's version as the most influential reinterpretation, Coltrane's solo, 1959 and 1967 versions, the documentary, Sally Swisher's lyrics.
- Thelonious Monk Discography — jazzdisco.org — WOR Studios, date, musicians, Blue Note 78 No. 1589 and BLP 5009; Riverside sessions of August 1957 and June 1959.
- Genius of Modern Music: Volume 2 — Wikipedia — Blue Note 1952 (BLP 5009), Alfred Lion, the 1951 session, "Four in One" and "Ask Me Now."
- Straight, No Chaser (composition) — Wikipedia — twelve-bar blues, first recording in 1951, later versions including Milestones.
- Thelonious Monk — Wikipedia — Minton's Playhouse, Blue Note 1947-1952, August 1951 arrest, cabaret card, concerts in Brooklyn, the Five Spot with Coltrane in 1957, Columbia in 1962, death on February 17, 1982.
- Monk did not take the rap for Bud — Lewis Porter (Substack) — date of August 8, 1951, car parked near Monk's home, heroin, sixty days in jail, cabaret card restored in 1957, challenge to the legend (per Peter Pullman and Robin Kelley).
- Thelonious Monk — Encyclopedia.com — cross-check of the arrest with Powell, the sixty days and the loss of the card; Columbia contract in 1962.
- Bartending terminology — Wikipedia — meaning of "straight" and "chaser."
- Chaser — Merriam-Webster — definition of "chaser."
- Straight, No Chaser — Ethan Hein (Substack) — cross-check of the structure (variations on one motif across the twelve bars), difficulty of learning it.
- Mulligan Meets Monk — Wikipedia — August 12-13, 1957, Riverside, musicians, inclusion of the tune.
- Milestones (Miles Davis album) — Wikipedia — session of February 4, 1958, Columbia, musicians, running time 10:41.
- 5 by Monk by 5 — Wikipedia — June 1959, Riverside, quintet with Thad Jones and Charlie Rouse.
- Straight, No Chaser (Thelonious Monk album) — Wikipedia — Columbia 1967, Teo Macero, quartet, running time 10:31.
- Thelonious Monk: Straight, No Chaser — Wikipedia — Charlotte Zwerin, Clint Eastwood as executive producer, the Blackwoods' footage for West German television, 1988 release, National Film Registry 2017.