Two men from Michigan
Gerald Marks was born in Michigan in 1900. He was eleven when a Saginaw bandleader played one of his compositions. He left school early and would go on to write more than a thousand songs. Seymour Simons was born in Detroit in 1896. A University of Michigan graduate, he built a career there as a pianist, composer and bandleader, then worked in radio from 1928 to 1932.
Together, they would score only one big success. All of Me was published in 1931 by Irving Berlin, Inc. The lyrics tell of a jilted lover who offers all of himself to the woman who left him, since he no longer knows what to do with it without her. The subject hit home: America in 1931 was living through one of the worst years in its economic history.
A song launched by a widow
To get the song heard, the writers turned to Belle Baker. She was a vaudeville star, the one who had introduced Irving Berlin's Blue Skies in 1926. In 1931, she sang All of Me on the radio, from the Fisher Theatre in Detroit.
That year, Belle Baker had just lost her husband, the songwriter Maurice Abrahams. The story handed down since then has it that her voice broke during the song and she burst into tears. The national press seized on the story. The public remembered the tune.
Two No. 1s in a few weeks
On December 1, 1931, Paul Whiteman and his orchestra recorded it with singer Mildred Bailey. According to reconstructed charts from the period, the record spent three weeks at the top. In late January 1932, Louis Armstrong cut his own version. It also reached No. 1. Within a few weeks, three different recordings were on the charts.
Hollywood followed. Fox slipped the song into Careless Lady, a 1932 comedy with Joan Bennett that critics panned. On the pop side, the momentum then faded. Jazz musicians, however, held on to the tune. On March 21, 1941, Billie Holiday recorded it in New York with Eddie Heywood's orchestra. Critic Ted Gioia considers it the definitive version, one nobody has topped since. That same year, Count Basie cut it with singer Lynne Sherman; the record charted in 1943.
From Sinatra to Willie Nelson
Frank Sinatra recorded it in 1947, then sang it on screen in Meet Danny Wilson, in 1952. The film revived the song, and Johnnie Ray had a hit with it the same year. Sinatra would come back to the tune four times over his career.
In 1978, the song found yet another audience. Willie Nelson included it on Stardust, an album of standards produced by Booker T. Jones. His version rose to No. 3 on the country chart. In 2000, the Songwriters Hall of Fame gave All of Me its Towering Song award.
What a guitarist finds in it
The form has four sections, ABAC, in the original key of B♭ major. There's a twenty-bar introductory verse, but almost nobody sings it.
The harmony is where it gets interesting. Right from the start, the tonic chord is followed by an unexpected dominant, built on the third degree: in C, you go from C to E7. That opening, which you also find in Charleston, kicks off a chain of dominants linked by fifths. It's a great school for learning to follow a cycle. Jazz musicians got the point: Lennie Tristano, Warne Marsh and others wrote new melodies over these changes.
What you need to know to play it
The changes are in C major, 32 bars (A B A C). They're built on secondary dominants: seventh chords that point to a degree other than the tonic. In the A section, each chord lasts two bars. After C6, E7 (the third degree made major) leads to A7, which leads to Dm7: the roots E, A, D move up in fourths, each dominant pulling toward the next.
The B section brings back E7, which this time resolves to Am7, the sixth degree. Then comes D7, the dominant of the dominant, for two bars. It turns into Dm7 (same root, flatted third), then G7 leads back to the A.
The C section speeds up, with one chord per bar. F6 becomes Fm6, the fourth degree borrowed from the minor mode, then Em7, A7, Dm7, G7 move up in fourths to C6. In the next-to-last bar, E♭dim7, a passing diminished chord, connects C6 to Dm7 through the bass (E♭, then D), and Dm7, G7 send the form around again.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the All of Me chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- C major, with one note changed per dominant. Stick with the C major scale and change just one note: G♯ over E7, C♯ over A7, F♯ over D7. Each of these notes is the third of the chord: aim for it, because it's what makes the dominant sound.
- The guide tones from E7 to Dm7. From E7 to A7, both guide tones move down a half step (D to C♯, G♯ to G). From A7 to Dm7, C♯ moves down a half step to C, but G moves down a whole step to F, the third of Dm7.
- The line from F6 to Em7. Aim for A over F6, A♭ over Fm6, then G over Em7: a line that moves down by half steps. The Fm6 arpeggio (F, A♭, C, D) differs from the F6 arpeggio only by that third.
- The passing diminished chord. E♭dim7 (E♭, G♭, A, C) keeps the C and the A of C6 and lowers the other two notes by a half step: E to E♭, G to G♭. On the neck, a diminished shape repeats identically every three frets.
The versions that matter
- Paul Whiteman and His Orchestra, vocal by Mildred Bailey — 78 recorded on December 1, 1931: the version that took the song to the top of the charts.
- Louis Armstrong and His Orchestra — 78 recorded in January 1932: a second No. 1 within a few weeks, and the tune's first step toward jazz.
- Billie Holiday with Eddie Heywood's orchestra — OKeh 78, No. 6214, 1941: the reading held up as definitive, with John Collins on guitar.
- Count Basie and His Orchestra, vocal by Lynne Sherman — 78 recorded in 1941, charted in 1943: Freddie Green's rhythm guitar at the heart of the section.
- Lester Young and Teddy Wilson — Pres and Teddy (Verve), recorded in 1956: a quartet with no guitar, but a lesson in relaxed phrasing over the changes.
- Willie Nelson — Stardust (Columbia), 1978: the standard as voice and guitar, carried all the way to the country audience.
Sources
- All of Me – JazzStandards.com — Belle Baker on the radio and at the Fisher Theatre, the widowhood story, Whiteman/Armstrong/Selvin chart positions, Careless Lady, Meet Danny Wilson (1952), Johnnie Ray, harmonic analysis (I–III7, cycle of fifths, kinship with Charleston), Lester Young/Teddy Wilson.
- All of Me (jazz standard) – Wikipedia — publisher Irving Berlin Inc., ABAC form in B♭, 20-bar verse, Whiteman on December 1, 1931, Armstrong at No. 1, Billie Holiday 1941 and Ted Gioia's assessment, Basie/Sherman at No. 14, Sinatra at No. 21, Willie Nelson at No. 3 country, contrafacts (Tristano, Marsh), Towering Song 2000.
- All of Me – Classic Jazz Standards — Belle Baker and the broken voice, recording dates (Armstrong January 27, 1932, Basie November 3, 1941, Sinatra October 19, 1947), guitarists on the sessions (John Collins, Freddie Green), Careless Lady (Fox).
- Stories of Standards: All of Me – KUVO — Belle Baker on the radio in 1931 after her husband's death, Whiteman December 1931, Towering Song 2000, Gerald Marks biography.
- All of Me – Songwriters Hall of Fame — 1931 as a crisis year, the writers' one-time collaboration, biographies of Marks (Saginaw, more than 1,000 songs) and Simons (Detroit, radio 1928–1932), Sinatra recorded it four times.
- Belle Baker – Wikipedia — husband Maurice Abrahams died in 1931, introduced Blue Skies in 1926.
- Columbia matrix 29990. All of me – Discography of American Historical Recordings (UCSB) — Billie Holiday and Eddie Heywood's orchestra, March 21, 1941, New York, OKeh 6214.
- Pres and Teddy – Wikipedia — recorded January 13, 1956, Verve, quartet lineup, All of Me as the opener.
- Stardust (Willie Nelson album) – Wikipedia — released April 1978, produced by Booker T. Jones, All of Me at No. 3 country, Nelson accompanying himself on guitar.
- Meet Danny Wilson – Wikipedia — confirms the film's 1952 date.