A pianist who played by ear
Erroll Garner was born in 1921 in Pittsburgh. He took to the piano as a small child, listening and reproducing what he heard. He never bothered to learn to read music. Asked about it on the set of the Tonight Show, he had his answer ready: "No one can hear you read." The line would give its title to a documentary in 2012.
That detail weighs heavily in the story of Misty. Garner composed from memory. An idea that came to him far from a piano had to stay in his head until he found a keyboard to play it on, and then get someone to write it down.
A melody born above the clouds
The most often repeated account comes from Garner himself, and its details vary from one telling to the next. The year is 1954. The pianist is flying from San Francisco to Chicago. During the descent, he sees a rainbow through the mist and the fogged-up windows. A melody comes to him. He hums it, eyes closed, tapping it out on his knees. The woman next to him thinks he's ill and calls the flight attendant. Other accounts put the scene on a flight from Chicago to New York, or have Garner thinking of his wife. So the anecdote is best taken as a musician's legend, told by the man himself, rather than as an official record.
What is established comes down to a date: on July 27, 1954, in Chicago, Garner recorded the tune with his trio, with Wyatt Ruther on bass and Fats Heard on drums. Misty came out on the album Contrasts, on EmArcy. The instrumental climbed as high as No. 30 in sales, a nice showing for a piano piece without lyrics.
Words, then voices
Johnny Burke, a star lyricist at Paramount who had won an Oscar for Swinging on a Star, then wrote lyrics, usually dated to 1955. The title and melody were handed to him. He chose tenderness over nostalgia: the tenderness of a defenseless lover, completely bowled over.
Dakota Staton was the first to record it with vocals, in 1957. But it was Johnny Mathis who made it a hit. He recorded it in New York in April 1959 for his album Heavenly. The single came out in September, reached No. 12 on the Billboard Hot 100 and became his signature song. The Mathis version entered the Grammy Hall of Fame in 2002, eleven years after Garner's, inducted in 1991.
From thriller to Nashville
In 1971, Clint Eastwood made his directing debut with Play Misty for Me. He plays a radio host stalked by a listener who keeps requesting the same song: Misty, in Garner's version. Eastwood reportedly paid $25,000 to use it. The tune picked up a menacing image, the opposite of its gentleness.
In 1975, singer Ray Stevens turned it into an upbeat country version, with banjo, fiddle and steel guitar. It reached No. 14 in the United States and earned him a Grammy for the arrangement. In 2001, Garner's original was ranked No. 174 on the "Songs of the Century" list compiled by the RIAA and the NEA.
What the changes tell us
Misty follows the classic 32-bar AABA form, originally in E♭ major. The bridge heads toward the subdominant key, A♭, then takes an unexpected detour before leading back to the theme. For a guitarist, it's ideal territory for working on extended chords and chord-melody playing, as Joe Pass showed in his solo work.
What you need to know to play it
Misty is a ballad in E♭ major, 32 bars long, A A B A form with eight-bar sections, at a slow tempo.
The A section starts on E♭maj7 and heads for the IV chord via a ii-V: B♭m7, E♭7, A♭maj7. Then A♭m7 and D♭7 (ivm7 and ♭VII7) lead back to E♭maj7 through another door, borrowed from E♭ minor. The second half is a classic turnaround: E♭maj7 Cm7, Fm7 B♭7, Gm7 C7, Fm7 B♭7 (I vi, ii V, iii VI7, ii V). The second A replaces the last two bars with E♭6, which closes the phrase.
The bridge picks up the ii-V into A♭maj7 again, this time with one bar per chord, and settles there for two bars. Then Am7 D7, a ii-V in G major, pulls the key away; the chart doesn't resolve to G and slides onto Fm7 then B♭7, the ii-V that leads back to the last A.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the Misty chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- The A♭ major scale over the ii-V-I. It covers B♭m7, E♭7 and A♭maj7. Coming from E♭maj7, only one note changes: D becomes D♭. The seventh of B♭m7, A♭, falls a half step to G, the third of E♭7; the seventh of E♭7, D♭, falls to C, the third of A♭maj7.
- The borrowing from minor. Over A♭m7 and D♭7, play the notes of E♭ natural minor (E♭, F, G♭, A♭, B♭, C♭, D♭). Listen to the C of A♭maj7 becoming C♭ on A♭m7: that half step is what darkens the phrase.
- The turnaround in the second half of the A. The E♭ major scale covers E♭maj7, Cm7, Fm7, Gm7 and B♭7. Only C7 is an exception: its third, E natural, replaces E♭.
- The D7 of the bridge. Over Am7 and D7, the G major scale. Aim for F♯, the third of D7: it falls a half step to the F of Fm7. At this slow tempo, let each target note ring rather than filling space.
The versions that matter
- Erroll Garner Trio — Contrasts (EmArcy), 1954: the original, recorded in Chicago, where the piano already sings like a voice.
- Johnny Mathis — Heavenly (Columbia), 1959: the version that made Misty a popular hit and Mathis' signature song.
- Richard "Groove" Holmes — Soul Message (Prestige), recorded in 1965: the Hammond organ pulls the ballad toward a funky swing, with Gene Edwards on guitar.
- Ray Stevens — Misty, 1975: a country reading, banjo and steel guitar up front, awarded a Grammy for the arrangement.
- Joe Pass — Virtuoso No. 2 (Pablo), 1976: solo guitar, first rubato then over a light swing; a lesson in chord melody.
Sources
- Misty (song) — Wikipedia EN — the San Francisco–Chicago flight story (after M. Brown, Smoketown), July 27, 1954 recording date and personnel, Dakota Staton 1957, Mathis chart figures, Ray Stevens, $25,000, Grammy Hall of Fame 1991 and 2002.
- Misty (chanson) — Wikipedia FR (in French) — variants of the anecdote, No. 30 for the instrumental, Hall of Fame, AABA form, modulation in the bridge, $25,000.
- Misty — jazzstandards.com — conflicting accounts of how it was written, Garner not reading music, chart positions (30, 12, 14), Ray Stevens, Groove Holmes, Joe Pass Virtuoso No. 2, analysis by K. J. McElrath (E♭, AABA, colors), tone of Burke's lyrics.
- Erroll Garner Wrote "Misty" — Jerry Jazz Musician — Garner's own account (interview with Art Taylor): San Francisco–Chicago flight, rainbow, seatmate calling the flight attendant.
- Artists You Should Know: Erroll Garner — KCRW — 1954 flight over Chicago, Garner playing by ear, the Tonight Show line.
- Erroll Garner — Wikipedia EN — born 1921 in Pittsburgh, self-taught, documentary No One Can Hear You Read (2012).
- Erroll Garner: The Joy of a Genius — NPR — birth, self-taught, never learned to read music.
- The Erroll Garner Jazz Project — NPR (transcript) — confirmation of his self-teaching and of Misty's role in his career.
- Misty – The Erroll Garner Story — Gachot Films — cross-check of the 1954 San Francisco–Chicago flight and the rainbow seen through the window.
- Contrasts (Erroll Garner album) — Wikipedia EN — EmArcy label, recorded in Chicago on July 27, 1954, personnel.
- Johnny Burke (lyricist) — Wikipedia EN — career at Paramount, Oscar for Swinging on a Star, Misty lyrics in 1955.
- Heavenly (Johnny Mathis album) — Wikipedia EN — recorded April 21, 1959, in New York, single released in September, No. 12, Hall of Fame 2002.
- Play Misty for Me — Wikipedia EN — Eastwood's first film as director, the song's role in the plot, 1971.
- Why Clint Eastwood Never Considered Another Song — /Film — $25,000 paid to Garner.
- Songs of the Century — UPI, 2001 — Misty by the Erroll Garner Trio, No. 174.
- Soul Message — Wikipedia EN — Groove Holmes, Prestige, recorded August 3, 1965, Gene Edwards on guitar.
- Virtuoso No. 2 — Wikipedia EN — Joe Pass, Pablo, 1976, Misty as track 4.