An afternoon in March 1959
On March 2, 1959, Miles Davis gathered his band at Columbia's 30th Street Studio in New York. It was the first of the two sessions for Kind of Blue. That same afternoon they cut "So What," "Freddie Freeloader" and "Blue in Green."
Davis had brought sketches rather than complete charts. The musicians rehearsed little and discovered the material almost on the spot. On "Blue in Green," alto saxophonist Cannonball Adderley sits out: it is the only track on the album he doesn't play on. That leaves Davis, John Coltrane, Bill Evans, Paul Chambers and Jimmy Cobb.
The first takes broke down quickly. Davis and Evans worked out the form in the studio, and it took four aborted attempts before they reached, on the fifth, the only complete version. The result runs five and a half minutes. Davis plays with a mute, Coltrane comes in without raising his voice, Evans sets the scene.
A form that turns in on itself
In the liner notes, Evans describes the piece as "a 10-measure circular form following a 4-measure introduction." Ten bars is unusual in jazz, where the ear expects blocks of eight, twelve or sixteen. Here the changes come back around before you have finished waiting for them.
No bridge, no chorus. Just a slow cycle of chords, over which each soloist stretches or shortens the note values at will. For a guitarist, it is less a song than a harmonic landscape to live in.
The pianist who had left
Bill Evans wasn't really in the band anymore. He joined Davis in the spring of 1958 and left in November, exhausted and worried about his father's health. Wynton Kelly took over the piano chair. But for this album, Davis called Evans back.
One episode turns up in several accounts: Davis is said to have handed Evans a sheet with two chords on it, G minor and A augmented according to NPR, and asked what he could do with them. From there, Evans supposedly developed the cycle you hear on the record. The timing of this episode, however, varies: a year before the session according to NPR, the following night according to others.
Who wrote "Blue in Green"?
The record credits Davis alone, and Davis, in his autobiography, claims every piece on the album. Evans signed it differently. On December 28, 1959, he recorded the tune with his new trio, Scott LaFaro on bass and Paul Motian on drums. On the album Portrait in Jazz, it is credited to Davis-Evans.
Twenty years later, as a guest on Marian McPartland's program Piano Jazz, taped in late 1978 and broadcast in 1979, Evans said he had written the tune, adding that he didn't "want to make a federal case out of it." According to his biographer Peter Pettinger, he had also asked for his share of the royalties and got only a 25-dollar check from Davis.
A friend of Evans's, the composer Earl Zindars, went further. In his view, the piece was entirely the pianist's work. He said he watched Evans compose it at his place, in the apartment where he was staying in East Harlem, playing the same passage over and over until three in the morning.
Davis himself wasn't consistent: in 1986 he reportedly told the poet Quincy Troupe, co-author of his autobiography, that he had written the tune with Evans. No document settles the matter for good. Credits vary from one record to the next: Davis alone, Davis and Evans, sometimes Evans alone. The most cautious version fits in one sentence: the initial idea may have come from Davis, but the tune as it is played bears Evans's harmonic signature.
From a quiet ballad to a standard
Kind of Blue came out in August 1959. Often called the best-selling jazz record in history, it was certified five times platinum in the United States in 2019. "Blue in Green" traveled with it.
Evans never let go of the tune: besides the Portrait in Jazz takes, at least nine unofficial recordings made between 1960 and 1979 are known, along with a 1978 studio version with Toots Thielemans. Guitarists took it up too, from John McLaughlin to Ralph Towner, from Kenny Burrell to Pat Martino. Its brevity and shifting harmony make it a demanding exercise: few bars, but not one where you can hide.
What to know before you play it
The changes last ten bars, an unusual length, and loop around: the last bar, Dm7, launches the first again. The tonal center is D minor, but the tonic doesn't open the cycle. You start on B♭maj7♯11 (the flatted sixth degree), pass through A7♯9 (the dominant) and land on Dm7 in the third bar.
The middle of the form descends by half steps: Dm7, D♭7, then Cm7 and F7, a ii-V that leads to B♭maj7 in the fifth bar. In the bass, D, D♭ and C slide down chromatically. Then B♭maj7, A7♯9 and Dm7 retrace the route from the beginning.
The last three bars take a detour. E7♯9, the dominant of A minor, resolves to Am7 in the ninth bar, before Dm7 closes the loop. The altered chords (♯9, ♯11) supply the color, and the very slow ballad tempo lets each chord ring: one chord per bar, except bars 3 and 4, which have two.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the Blue in Green chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- Lydian over B♭maj7♯11. Play D natural minor (the notes of F major): over B♭maj7, it brings out E, the augmented fourth that gives you the ♯11. Aim for that E and for A, the seventh of the chord.
- A7♯9 to Dm7. Take the A7 arpeggio (A, C♯, E, G) and add C natural, the sharp nine: the rub between C and C♯ is the color. To resolve, C♯ moves up a half step to D, and G moves down a whole step to F, the third of Dm7.
- The descent in bars 3 to 5. Play Dm7, D♭7 and Cm7 with the root on the A string, at the 5th, 4th and then 3rd fret, to hear the bass slide. Over Cm7 and F7, the seventh of Cm7 (B♭) falls a half step to the third of F7 (A), and that A stays put to become the seventh of B♭maj7.
- The detour through A minor. Over E7♯9, use A harmonic minor: its G♯, the third of E7, moves up a half step to the A of Am7. This scale doesn't have the chord's ♯9 (G natural): add it as a passing tone, just below the G♯. At this tempo, a few well-chosen notes are worth more than a scale run.
The versions that matter
- Miles Davis — Kind of Blue (Columbia), 1959: the original version, muted trumpet and Evans's piano, without Cannonball Adderley.
- Bill Evans Trio — Portrait in Jazz (Riverside), recorded in 1959, released in 1960: Evans's own reading with LaFaro and Motian, and the first shared Davis-Evans credit.
- John McLaughlin — My Goal's Beyond (Douglas), 1971: a miniature on acoustic guitar, on the side of the record where McLaughlin plays almost alone.
- Ralph Towner and Gary Burton — Slide Show (ECM), recorded in 1985, released in 1986: a guitar-vibraphone dialogue, credited to Bill Evans alone.
- Cassandra Wilson — Traveling Miles (Blue Note), 1999: renamed "Sky & Sea," with new lyrics and Pat Metheny on classical guitar.
Sources
- Blue in Green — Wikipedia — recording date, Adderley's absence, ten-bar form per Evans's notes, false starts, successive credits, Evans's claim on McPartland's show, the 25-dollar check, Zindars's account, list of covers.
- Blue in Green — Wikipedia (in French) — unusual ten-bar form, Davis's claim in his autobiography, Zindars's account, theory of changes supplied by Davis, versions.
- Kind of Blue — Wikipedia — 30th Street Studio, dates of the two sessions, sketches and little rehearsal, Evans's departure and replacement by Wynton Kelly, 2019 RIAA certification.
- Bill Evans — Wikipedia — joining Davis in 1958, leaving in November 1958 and why, return for Kind of Blue, the two-chord sheet, the 25-dollar check.
- Between Takes: The Kind Of Blue Sessions — NPR — personnel on the tune, interrupted takes, form worked out in the studio by Davis and Evans.
- Miles Davis: Kind of Blue — NPR — two-chord sheet handed by Davis to Evans, status as the best-selling jazz album.
- How My Heart Sings, by Peter Pettinger, as cited by Wikipedia, Blue in Green article — the 25-dollar check; Evans's quote "I don't want to make a federal case out of it" (show broadcast May 27, 1979); Davis to Quincy Troupe in 1986; at least nine unofficial Evans recordings (1960-1979), the Affinity version (1978).
- Bill Evans On Piano Jazz — NPR — taping (November 6, 1978) and broadcast (May 27, 1979) dates of the show.
- Earl Zindars and Bill Evans — All About Jazz — Zindars's account: composed in his East Harlem apartment, until 3 a.m.
- Bill Evans talks about Miles' music — Musicplayer forum — cross-check (secondary source) of Evans's claim and the 25-dollar check, transcribed from a 1979 radio interview.
- Portrait in Jazz — Wikipedia — date (December 28, 1959), trio, Davis-Evans credit, 1960 release.
- Blue in Green — JazzStandards.com — year, credit to Davis, versions by guitarists (McLaughlin, Burrell, Pat Martino).
- My Goal's Beyond — Wikipedia — year, label, solo acoustic guitar on side B, Davis/Evans credit.
- Slide Show — Wikipedia — Towner and Burton, ECM, dates, credit to Bill Evans.
- Traveling Miles — Wikipedia — title "Sky & Sea," new lyrics by Wilson, Pat Metheny on classical guitar.