A band in search of a second wind
In the early 1950s, the Duke Ellington Orchestra hit a rough patch. In 1951, three pillars walked out: saxophonist Johnny Hodges, trombonist Lawrence Brown and drummer Sonny Greer. Hodges wouldn't come back until 1955.
In early 1953, Ellington left Columbia for Capitol, a younger label he hoped would promote him better. His first session for the new label took place on April 6, 1953. Among the sides cut that day was "Satin Doll," as an instrumental.
The bet paid off fast. The record entered the sales charts in June 1953 and climbed to No. 27. Not a landslide, but a real hit for a band weakened by departures. The big comeback would come three years later, at the Newport festival, in 1956.
Duke's sketch, Strayhorn's touch
The work was shared. According to biographer David Hajdu, Ellington came up with the main motif, then handed it to Billy Strayhorn to harmonize and orchestrate.
Strayhorn also wrote a first lyric. It was judged not commercial enough and was never used. So the tune was born without words.
And the title? According to Hajdu, it was Strayhorn's nickname for his mother, Lillian, whom his lyric paid tribute to. Other theories exist, though, notably that it referred to Evie Ellis, Ellington's longtime companion, a claim made by his son Mercer Ellington in his memoir. No one has ever settled it.
Harmonically, the tune is in C major. It moves through short pairs of ii-V chords that seem to slide from one key center to the next, and its bridge passes briefly through F, then G. The changes are easy to memorize, but full of moves to negotiate.
Enter Mercer
Lyricist Johnny Mercer was also one of the co-founders of Capitol. About five years after Ellington's record, he wrote new lyrics. A version with words was registered in 1958, and sheet music was published in 1960.
With lyrics, the tune took on a new life. Ella Fitzgerald, who had already recorded a scat version in 1957, sang it with Mercer's words in 1961 (Ella in Hollywood), then again in 1963 alongside Count Basie, with arrangements by Quincy Jones. "Satin Doll" settled into the standard repertoire for good.
A family feud in court
Who wrote what? The question came back decades later. In the early 1990s, the Ellington and Strayhorn estates faced off in federal court in New York. At the heart of the dispute: should Strayhorn's heirs collect royalties when the tune is played without lyrics?
The paperwork contradicted itself. Both sides agreed that the instrumental melody registered in 1953 belonged to Ellington alone. But the 1958 registration credited only him for the music (Strayhorn and Mercer were listed for the lyrics), while the 1960 one added Strayhorn to the music. A 1954 contract, however, had split the rights three ways, equally, among Ellington, Strayhorn and Mercer.
In 1993, the judge declined to rule on the papers alone and sent the case to trial. Along the way, he accepted a principle every musician will appreciate: the harmony of an arrangement can, legally, be protected, because originality lies in the creative work, not just in novelty.
What you need to know to play it
The changes are in C major, 32 bars (A A B A). They're built almost entirely from ii-V pairs, two chords per bar, chained together without resolving. The A section plays Dm7, G7, the ii-V of C, twice, then moves up a whole step to play Em7, A7 twice. Next comes Am7, D7, then the same pair a half step lower: A♭m7, D♭7. That last ii-V replaces Dm7, G7 through tritone substitution: D♭7 contains the same tritone as G7 (F and C♭, which is B), and it slides down a half step to Cmaj7, which finally arrives in bar 7 and lasts two bars.
The bridge heads to the fourth degree. Gm7, C7, played twice, is the ii-V of F major, and this time it resolves, onto Fmaj7, for two bars. Then Am7, D7, twice (the ii-V of G), and Dm7, G7, one bar each, lead back to the last A.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the Satin Doll chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- One scale per ii-V. Play each pair with the major scale it points to: C major over Dm7, G7; D major over Em7, A7; G major over Am7, D7; G♭ major over A♭m7, D♭7. With two chords per bar, think in pairs, not chord by chord.
- The same fingering, moved. Work out a phrase over Dm7, G7, then play it again two frets higher over Em7, A7. Same idea from Am7, D7 to A♭m7, D♭7, this time one fret lower.
- D♭7 to Cmaj7. The third of D♭7 (F) moves down a half step to the third of Cmaj7 (E), and its seventh (C♭, which is B) stays put and becomes the seventh of Cmaj7. Just before that, the seventh of A♭m7 (G♭) moves down a half step to F.
- The bridge in F. F major covers the first four bars of the bridge (Gm7, C7, Fmaj7). Over Am7, D7, switch to G major (F♯), then go back to C major over Dm7 and G7.
The versions that matter
- Duke Ellington and His Orchestra — Capitol single, 1953 (reissued on the compilation The Capitol Sessions 1953-1955): the original instrumental version, from the first Capitol session.
- Barney Kessel, Ray Brown, Shelly Manne — The Poll Winners (Contemporary), 1957: a piano-less trio where the guitar carries both the melody and the harmony on its own.
- Wes Montgomery Trio — The Wes Montgomery Trio (Riverside), recorded in 1959, released in 1960: Wes's guitar in a trio with Melvin Rhyne on organ and Paul Parker on drums, with two takes of the tune on the reissues.
- Ella Fitzgerald and Count Basie — Ella and Basie! (Verve), 1963: the benchmark vocal version, with Mercer's lyrics and Quincy Jones's arrangements.
- Joe Pass — Portraits of Duke Ellington (Pablo), recorded in 1974, released in 1975: the tune opens the album, in a trio with Ray Brown and Bobby Durham.
Sources
- Satin Doll — Wikipedia — year, roles of Ellington and Strayhorn according to Hajdu, Strayhorn's unused lyric, nickname of Strayhorn's mother, dating of Mercer's lyric and the 1960 registration, versions (Ella 1957, 1961 and 1963, Kessel 1957, Capitol Sessions).
- Satin Doll — JazzStandards.com — Capitol session of April 6, 1953, chart position (No. 27, June 1953), Strayhorn's role, Mercer's lyrics about five years later, the Evie Ellis theory, key of C and bridge in F and G, existence of the Tempo Music v. Famous Music lawsuit.
- Satin Doll — Classic Jazz Standards — move from Columbia to Capitol in early 1953, first session on April 6, 1953, Strayhorn's lyric judged uncommercial, Mercer as Capitol co-founder, chart entry on June 13, 1953 and No. 27 peak, versions.
- Satin Doll — The 1937 Flood Watch — hope for better promotion at Capitol, Ellington's sketch and Strayhorn's work, first name of Strayhorn's mother (Lillian), the Evie Ellis theory from Mercer Ellington's memoir (1978).
- Duke Ellington — Wikipedia — departures of Hodges, Brown and Greer in 1951, Hodges's return in 1955, the Capitol years, the 1956 Newport comeback.
- Tempo Music v. Famous Music, 838 F. Supp. 162 (S.D.N.Y. 1993) — GWU Music Copyright Infringement Resource — subject of the dispute, the 1953, 1958 and 1960 registrations, the 1954 three-way contract, the principle that harmony can be protected, referral to trial.
- The Poll Winners — Wikipedia — date, label, Kessel-Brown-Manne trio, inclusion of "Satin Doll."
- The Wes Montgomery Trio — Wikipedia — recording (October 1959) and release (1960) dates, Riverside, Melvin Rhyne, inclusion of "Satin Doll."
- Ella and Basie! — Wikipedia — date (July 1963), Verve, Quincy Jones arrangements, inclusion of "Satin Doll."
- Portraits of Duke Ellington — Wikipedia — Joe Pass, recorded 1974, released 1975, Pablo, Ray Brown and Bobby Durham, "Satin Doll" as the opener.