Isham Jones, 1920s hitmaker
To understand this tune, you have to go back to the man who wrote it. Isham Jones was born in 1894 in Ohio. In Chicago, he led one of the most popular dance bands of the 1920s. His first big hit, Wabash Blues, dates from 1921. With lyricist Gus Kahn, he went on to write a string of songs that have lasted a century, including It Had to Be You and I'll See You in My Dreams, in 1924.
His band mostly played "sweet" music, smooth and danceable. But Jones had an ear for good songs and for good musicians. Among others, he hired a young clarinetist and saxophonist, Woody Herman, and the arranger Gordon Jenkins.
1936: a farewell song
In 1936, Jones teamed up with Marty Symes, a New York lyricist with a small catalog but plenty of hits, such as Under a Blanket of Blue and It's the Talk of the Town. The lyric is simple and direct: a declaration of absolute love, written with a deliberately limited vocabulary.
On February 3, 1936, in New York, the Isham Jones Orchestra recorded the song for Decca. It came out as the B side of Life Begins When You're in Love. The record entered the hit parade in April, for one week, at No. 20. A modest success, and one of the band's last. That same year, Jones, tired of the demands of a bandleader's life, retired. Woody Herman took over some of his musicians and launched his own band, which recorded for Decca as early as November 1936. It was the start of a half-century career as a bandleader.
Ellington, Billie, Dinah: the ballad makes its way
The song didn't stay Jones's property for long. On February 27, 1936, barely three weeks after him, Duke Ellington recorded it with singer Ivie Anderson. Billie Holiday cut it for Decca on February 13, 1947. In 1954, Dinah Washington delivered a short, intense version on Dinah Jams, surrounded by Clifford Brown and Max Roach, among others.
Through the 1930s, the 1940s and the early 1950s, There Is No Greater Love was mostly played as a ballad. It had a reputation for being comfortable for singers.
Swing takes over
In the mid-1950s, jazz musicians picked up the tempo. On November 16, 1955, Miles Davis recorded it for Prestige with his new quintet, as a relaxed swing. John Coltrane, though a member of the group, doesn't play on this track. In 1957, Sonny Rollins took it up on Way Out West, in a trio with Ray Brown on bass and Shelly Manne on drums, with no piano or guitar to lay down the chords. On February 12, 1964, Miles Davis played it again in concert at Philharmonic Hall in New York, with Herbie Hancock, Ron Carter and Tony Williams, at a much faster tempo.
The changes explain this flexibility. It's a 32-bar AABA form, originally in B♭ major. The A sections start like a blues, from the first degree to the fourth with a seventh, then return to the tonic through a cycle of fifths. The bridge swings over to the relative minor, G minor. Clear harmony that holds up just as well slow as fast. Proof of its staying power: in 2003, Amy Winehouse still put it on her first album, Frank.
What you need to know to play it
There Is No Greater Love is in B♭ major, 32 bars, A A B A with eight-bar sections, at a medium swing tempo.
The A section starts like a blues: B♭maj7, then B♭7, which pushes toward the fourth degree, E♭7, held for two bars. The second half is a turnaround: B♭maj7 G7, Cm7 F7, Dm7 G7, Cm7 F7 (I VI7, ii V, iii VI7, ii V). In this turnaround, G7, the dominant of Cm7, is the only chord outside the B♭ major scale. The last A lands on B♭maj7 in bar 7, then Cm7 F7 sends the tune around again.
The bridge passes through the relative minor: Am7♭5, D7, Gm7, a ii-V-i in G minor, with Gm7 held for two bars. C7 (the II7) takes up two bars in turn, then Cm7 and F7, one bar each, lead back to the A.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the There Is No Greater Love chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- The line through the first three bars. Aim for A over B♭maj7, A♭ over B♭7, G over E♭7: the major seventh, the seventh, then the third of E♭7 move down by half steps. Over the two bars of E♭7, use the A♭ major scale (E♭ Mixolydian).
- The turnaround. The B♭ major scale covers the last four bars of the A section, except G7: its third, B natural, moves up a half step to the C of Cm7.
- The bridge in G minor. Over Am7♭5 and D7, G harmonic minor; aim for F♯, the third of D7, which moves up a half step to the G of Gm7. Over Gm7, the B♭ major scale; over C7, the F major scale, where E natural replaces E♭.
- Comping in four. Play short chords on all four beats, with three-note voicings (root, third, seventh) on the low strings. On the chords that last two bars (E♭7, Gm7, C7), vary the voicing rather than the rhythm.
The versions that matter
- Isham Jones and His Orchestra — Decca 704, 1936: the original, as a B side, in the dance style of the day.
- Billie Holiday — Decca 23853, 1947: the sung ballad, with orchestra, eleven years after it was introduced.
- Miles Davis Quintet — Miles: The New Miles Davis Quintet (Prestige), recorded in 1955: the move to medium swing, without Coltrane on this track.
- Sonny Rollins — Way Out West (Contemporary), 1957: the saxophone alone with bass and drums, a lesson in harmonic freedom.
- Miles Davis — Four & More (Columbia), recorded live in 1964: a fast, edgy version by the quintet with Hancock, Carter and Williams.
- Lenny Breau — Live at Bourbon St. (Guitarchives), recorded in Toronto in 1983: in a duo with bassist Dave Young, Breau's seven-string guitar makes this tune the album's opening track.
Sources
- There Is No Greater Love — jazzstandards.com — introduced by the Isham Jones Orchestra as a B side, No. 20 in April 1936, Jones's retirement and handover to Woody Herman, Dinah Washington, a ballad comfortable for singers, the shift from ballad to medium swing, Miles 1955 (without Coltrane) and 1964, Rollins, analysis of the form and harmony, simplicity of Symes's lyric.
- There Is No Greater Love — Wikipedia — writers, 1936, A side Life Begins When You're in Love, last hit before Herman took over, Billie Holiday 1947, Amy Winehouse 2003, Lenny Breau.
- Decca matrix 60430 — Discography of American Historical Recordings (UCSB) — Isham Jones recording of February 3, 1936 in New York, Decca 704, Woody Herman on reeds.
- Brunswick matrix B18735 — Discography of American Historical Recordings (UCSB) — Duke Ellington, February 27, 1936, New York, with Ivie Anderson.
- Decca matrix 73793 — Discography of American Historical Recordings (UCSB) — Billie Holiday, February 13, 1947, Decca 23853.
- Isham Jones — Wikipedia — born in 1894 in Ohio, Wabash Blues, songs with Gus Kahn, departure from Decca and band taken over by Herman in 1936.
- Isham Jones — jazzstandards.com — "sweet" band, musicians (Woody Herman, Gordon Jenkins), Wabash Blues 1921, songs from 1924, retirement in 1936.
- Woody Herman — Wikipedia — Jones tired of leading, Herman takes over the band, first Decca recording on November 6, 1936.
- Marty Symes — Wikipedia — Brooklyn-born lyricist, Under a Blanket of Blue and It's the Talk of the Town (1933).
- Marty Symes — jazzstandards.com — small catalog but rich in hits, same 1933 titles.
- Dinah Jams — Wikipedia — recorded in 1954 in Los Angeles, Clifford Brown, Max Roach.
- Miles: The New Miles Davis Quintet — Wikipedia — November 16, 1955, Prestige, Coltrane absent from the track.
- Four & More — Wikipedia — concert of February 12, 1964 at Philharmonic Hall, tune on the program.
- Way Out West (Sonny Rollins album) — Wikipedia — March 7, 1957, Contemporary, chordless trio with Ray Brown and Shelly Manne.
- Live at Bourbon St. — Wikipedia — Lenny Breau, June 14, 1983 in Toronto, released 1995 on Guitarchives, opening track.
- Lenny Breau with Dave Young: Live at Bourbon St. — Jazz Music Archives — cross-check, seven-string electric guitar.
- Amy Winehouse — Frank — Jazz Music Archives — (There Is) No Greater Love as track 7 of the 2003 album.