Room 414, Gunter Hotel
San Antonio, Texas, November 23, 1936. At the Gunter Hotel, producer Don Law of the ARC company had turned room 414 into a studio. The recording console sat in the bedroom; the musician played in the sitting room. That day there was only one musician: Robert Johnson, his voice and his guitar.
Johnson was probably 25. He was born, most likely on May 8, 1911, in Hazlehurst, Mississippi. He cut eight songs on that first day, among them Kind Hearted Woman Blues, I Believe I'll Dust My Broom, Terraplane Blues and Sweet Home Chicago. Two more sessions followed in San Antonio on November 26 and 27, then two days in Dallas in June 1937. Altogether, those sessions produced 29 songs.
Sweet Home Chicago came out in 1937 on Vocalion 78 No. 03601, backed with Walkin' Blues. Sources disagree on the exact month, July or August. The track runs 2:59. Johnson died on August 16, 1938, near Greenwood, Mississippi, at 27, after eleven 78s released in his lifetime.
A song once called Kokomo
Johnson didn't build Sweet Home Chicago from scratch. It belongs to a family of blues that had been going around since the late 1920s. In 1928, guitarist Scrapper Blackwell recorded Kokomo Blues. According to Elijah Wald, he may have been the first in that family to name a specific town, most likely Kokomo, Indiana.
The best-known relative arrived in 1934. On September 10, in Chicago, James Arnold cut Old Original Kokomo Blues for Decca. Most sources give that date; the song's Wikipedia page says 1933. The record became the family's best-selling pre-war disc, and it gave the musician his nickname: Kokomo Arnold. Arnold himself muddied the waters about some of the words. In an interview quoted by Paul Oliver, he tied them to a brand of coffee and a Chicago drugstore.
Other variants orbit around them: Madlyn Davis's Kokola Blues (1927), Jabo Williams's Ko Ko Mo Blues (1932), Charlie McCoy's Baltimore Blues (1934), Freddie Spruell's Mr. Freddie's Kokomo Blues (1935). The melody itself goes back to older pieces, Honey Dripper Blues and Red Cross Blues. Small wonder, then, that the authorship of Sweet Home Chicago is disputed. Kokomo Arnold claimed his share. And in 1958, on Junior Parker's single, the songwriting credit went to pianist Roosevelt Sykes.
What Johnson changed
What sets Johnson's version apart comes down to a few choices. He swapped Kokomo for Chicago. He slipped California in where Arnold had another line. He sang the first verse as a chorus that keeps coming back. According to the Blues Foundation, Johnson may have been the first to use the phrase "Sweet Home Chicago."
On guitar, he dropped the bottleneck Arnold played with. According to an analysis cited by Wikipedia, he transferred to the guitar the boogie bass lines of pianists such as Roosevelt Sykes and Walter Roland. His thumb pounds that figure on the low strings while his fingers drop phrases on top, so that listeners often think they hear two guitars. Above it all, his voice climbs high, close to falsetto.
Chicago, California: the map puzzle
The story fits in one sentence: a man urges a woman to leave with him for Chicago, the "sweet home" of the title. But the chorus pairs Chicago with California, two places a very long way apart. In the 1960s and 1970s, several writers put it down to a simple geography mistake.
Other readings followed. For the Chicago Tribune in 2002, Johnson was sketching an imaginary paradise that joins the North and the West. Some have heard a narrator's trick, or a travel route. Some point to California Avenue, a Chicago street. Greenberg, in his book Love in Vain, suggests Port Chicago, a town in California. Max Haymes hears a choice: California or Chicago. The Blues Foundation settles it cautiously: the meaning is still debated.
From 78 to jam-session anthem
The song started traveling fast. According to Wikipedia, Tommy McClennan borrowed Johnson's chorus as early as 1939 for Baby Don't You Want to Go, and Walter Davis did the same in 1941. In 1955, Roosevelt Sykes recorded it as Sweet Old Chicago. Three years later, Junior Parker turned it into a band shuffle with harmonica, on Duke: it reached No. 13 on Billboard's R&B chart, the first electric version to become a hit.
Johnson's original resurfaced later. Around 1967, a bootleg LP put it out, on a label named, of all things, Kokomo. In 1970, Columbia included it on King of the Delta Blues Singers, Vol. II. The first volume, released in 1961, had left it off.
In the meantime, Magic Sam had recorded his version in 1967 at Sound Studios in Chicago, with Mighty Joe Young on second guitar, for the album West Side Soul. Jim O'Neal rates it among the best ever recorded. He also points out that it predates the era when the song became the obligatory sing-along of Chicago blues bands.
Then came 1980. In the final concert of the film The Blues Brothers, John Belushi dedicated the song to Magic Sam, with Steve Cropper and Matt "Guitar" Murphy on guitars. That version turned it into a worldwide jam-session anthem. Steve LaVere compared the song to When the Saints Go Marching In: a tune every blues fan knows by heart. On February 21, 2012, at the Red, White and Blues evening at the White House, Barack Obama is reported to have sung a few words of it, egged on by Buddy Guy and B.B. King.
Why did Johnson's version eclipse its cousins? The Blues Foundation suggests three reasons: reissues by a major label, its bass line, which some see as a backbone of rock 'n' roll, and the pull of Chicago as a destination. The honors followed. The recording entered the Blues Hall of Fame in 1983, among the very first inductees, then the Grammy Hall of Fame in 2014. The Rock and Roll Hall of Fame lists it among the 500 Songs That Shaped Rock and Roll.
What you need to know to play it
The version you'll hear at a jam is the Magic Sam and Blues Brothers one: an electric shuffle in E, in standard tuning, around 125 beats per minute (the tempo drifts on the long Blues Brothers version). It's a twelve-bar blues with a quick change.
The quick change means going to the IV chord as early as bar 2. You play E7 (the I chord) in bar 1, A7 (the IV) in bar 2, then back to E7 for bars 3 and 4. The rest is the classic blues: A7 in bars 5 and 6, E7 in bars 7 and 8. The last phrase steps down B7 (the V), A7, E7, and bar 12 goes back up to B7 to kick off the next chorus: that's the turnaround.
Plenty of bands keep bar 2 on E7, with no quick change. Others fill the ending differently: E7 then A7 in bar 11, E7 then B7 in bar 12. One transcription of the Blues Brothers version also shows a chromatic climb, B♭ then B, back into bar 1. Agree on it before you count off.
Johnson's original is another story. He played it solo, in standard tuning with a capo at the 2nd fret according to Guitar World, and his twelve bars contain slight irregularities. Even its exact key is uncertain: according to a disputed theory, his records were sped up when they were pressed.
You can play the full chord chart of Sweet Home Chicago in Guitar Master, in Band Jam.
What to play over it on guitar
- The fifth-to-sixth shuffle. This is the basic rhythm part. Over E7, the open low E string is the bass, and on the A string you alternate the fifth, B (2nd fret), and the sixth, C♯ (4th fret). The Magic Sam lesson stretches the finger up to the 5th fret before coming back to the 2nd. Over A7, same pattern one string over: open A, then the D string. Over B7, grab the chord and pick its bass notes separately. Rest your palm near the bridge to mute the strings.
- The E minor pentatonic, plus G♯. E, G, A, B, D, in open position or at the 12th fret. Over E7, bend the G up toward G♯, the chord's third: the rub between the two is the heart of the blues sound. Add B♭, the flatted fifth, as a passing note and you have the E blues scale.
- Make the quick change count. In bar 2, the pentatonic's G becomes the seventh of A7, and C♯ is its third. Aim for either one to make the change heard right at the top of the chart. Over B7, aim for D♯, its third, which moves up a half step to E.
- Magic Sam's turnarounds. He played with his fingers, no pick. For bars 11 and 12, try triplets coming down from the 3rd fret of the B string, or sixths on the G and high E strings sliding down into an E chord.
- A nod to Johnson. For the intro or the ending, hold the high E at the 12th fret of the high E string while the bass walks down, as some lessons show. And if you're playing alone, try the thumbed boogie bass on the low strings with a few high notes on top: that's the whole idea of the 1936 recording.
The versions that matter
- Robert Johnson — Vocalion 78 No. 03601, recorded 1936, released 1937: the solo original, with the thumbed boogie bass and the near-falsetto voice.
- Kokomo Arnold — Old Original Kokomo Blues, Decca, 1934: the direct ancestor, played with a slide.
- Roosevelt Sykes — Sweet Old Chicago, 1955: a pianist's reading, with reworked lyrics.
- Little Junior Parker & His Band — Duke single, 1958: a band shuffle with harmonica, No. 13 on the R&B chart, the first electric hit version.
- Magic Sam — West Side Soul (Delmark), recorded 1967, released 1968: the West Side version that set the template for the modern electric shuffle. The album has been in the Blues Hall of Fame since 1984.
- The Blues Brothers — The Blues Brothers, film and soundtrack (Atlantic), 1980: the closing concert, dedicated to Magic Sam, that made the song the anthem of jam sessions around the world.
Sources
- Sweet Home Chicago — Wikipedia EN — November 23, 1936 session, running time, ancestors (Blackwell, Arnold and the other variants), what Johnson changed, the geography debate, McClennan, Davis, Sykes, Junior Parker, Magic Sam, Blues Brothers, LaVere, the 2012 White House evening, honors.
- Sweet Home Chicago — Wikipedia FR (in French) — Gunter Hotel, versions, Blues Hall of Fame 1983, Rock and Roll Hall of Fame list.
- Blues Hall of Fame: Sweet Home Chicago — Blues Foundation — Vocalion 03601, 1967 and 1970 reissues, dated ancestors, Elijah Wald, first use of the phrase, debated meaning, reasons for its staying power, bar-band standard.
- Robert Johnson recordings — Wikipedia EN — session dates and places, the room set up by Don Law, 29 songs, first-day titles.
- The San Antonio blues — Texas Highways — November 23, 1936, room 414, Don Law, eight songs recorded that day.
- Robert Johnson — Wikipedia EN — born in Hazlehurst, died near Greenwood in 1938.
- Robert Johnson — 45worlds — Vocalion 78s released in his lifetime, release date of Vocalion 03601.
- Kokomo Arnold, Old Original Kokomo Blues — DAHR — recorded in Chicago on September 10, 1934.
- Kokomo Arnold — Wikipedia EN — nickname, Kokomo (Indiana), Arnold's explanations quoted by Paul Oliver.
- Junior Parker — Wikipedia EN — 1958 Duke single, No. 13 on the R&B chart.
- West Side Soul — Wikipedia EN — Magic Sam: 1967 recording, Mighty Joe Young, 1968 release, Jim O'Neal's verdict, Blues Hall of Fame 1984.
- The Blues Brothers: Music from the Soundtrack — Wikipedia EN — 1980 release, Steve Cropper and Matt Murphy.
- Grammy Hall of Fame 2014 — Recording Academy (PR Newswire) — Grammy Hall of Fame induction in 2014.
- 500 Songs That Shaped Rock and Roll — Western Michigan University — inclusion in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame list.
- Sweet Home Chicago backing track — Karaoke Version — Blues Brothers version in E, about 125 BPM, variable tempo.
- Magic Sam, Sweet Home Chicago guitar lesson — Jon MacLennan — full chart in E with quick change, shuffle, fingerstyle playing, turnarounds.
- Sweet Home Chicago chords — Ultimate Guitar — Blues Brothers chart in E, chromatic climb, variants.
- Sweet Home Chicago — JustinGuitar — E, twelve bars, shuffle, palm muting.
- Sweet Home Chicago tutorial — The Blues Guitar — Johnson-style intro, variations in the original.
- Unlocking the guitar mysteries of Robert Johnson — Guitar World — standard tuning with capo at the 2nd fret, thumbed bass, the sped-up records theory.