The pianist with the paralyzed arm
Roy Hawkins was born in 1903 in Jefferson, Texas. By the mid-1940s he was playing the clubs of Oakland, California. That's where producer Bob Geddins spotted him, won over by his dark, intense style. In 1949, Hawkins signed with Modern Records in Los Angeles.
Then everything changed. A serious car accident left him with a paralyzed arm. While he was in the hospital, Geddins wrote him a blues about bad luck, Why Do Everything Happen to Me. The record climbed to No. 2 on Billboard's R&B chart in early 1950. In the studio, other hands now played the piano, and arranger Maxwell Davis took over production.
A slow blues in a minor key
In 1951, Hawkins recorded The Thrill Is Gone, written with Rick Darnell. It's a slow blues in a minor key, sung by a man who realizes love has died out and decides to move on. In July 1951 the record reached No. 6 on the R&B chart. As often happened at the time, the songwriting credits would shift for years: depending on the edition, other names appear alongside, or in place of, those of the two writers.
Hawkins left Modern in 1954, recorded for other labels, then vanished from the studios in the early 1960s. His song, though, had found an attentive listener. In Memphis, a young disc jockey was playing it on the air. His name was B.B. King.
New York, 1969: the last take
Nearly twenty years later, in 1969, King recorded the album Completely Well in New York with a producer just starting out, Bill Szymczyk, who would later work with the Eagles. The Thrill Is Gone was the last song of the last session.
Around King and his Gibson guitar, nicknamed Lucille, the studio gathered Paul Harris on electric piano, Hugh McCracken on guitar, Gerald Jemmott on bass and Herbie Lovelle on drums. King started the minor-key riff, and Harris followed right away. A few run-throughs, and the keeper came on the third try. King sang live with the band.
Strings to cross the line
That's when Szymczyk had an idea: add strings. The arrangement went to Bert DeCoteaux, and a section of about a dozen players was recorded roughly a week later. For a blues record, that was a break with tradition. Szymczyk saw it as the push that would open up the pop charts. He later summed it up for Mix magazine: "this was the track that took him off the 'chitlin' circuit and put him in Vegas."
The gamble paid off. The single came out on BluesWay in December 1969, in a version cut down to under four minutes. It rose to No. 3 on the R&B chart and No. 15 on the Billboard Hot 100. No King record would ever climb higher on the pop charts. The song won him the Grammy for Best Male R&B Vocal Performance, presented in 1971 at the 13th ceremony, for the year 1970. King made it his signature song.
The accolades followed. The 1969 version entered the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1998 and was ranked No. 183 on Rolling Stone's list of the 500 greatest songs of all time. For a guitarist, it remains a lesson: few notes, lots of space, and every phrase from Lucille answering the voice.
What you need to know to play it
The Thrill Is Gone is a twelve-bar minor blues in B minor, played slowly, with straight eighth notes, no shuffle. The twelve bars break down into three four-bar phrases.
The first phrase stays on Bm7, the i chord, for four bars. The second spends two bars on Em7, the iv chord, then comes back to Bm7 for two. The third carries the tune's signature: instead of the usual blues cadence, Gmaj7 (the flatted sixth, ♭VImaj7) drops a half step to F♯7, the dominant (V7), in bar 10, and the chart settles on Bm7 for the last two bars.
F♯7 is the only chord outside B natural minor: its third, A♯, is the leading tone that pulls toward B. All the other chords fit in that scale.
Get the chart as a PDF, in your key
Pick a key and the preview follows. Leave your email and the The Thrill Is Gone chart lands in your inbox, ready to print, with the degree under each chord.
What to play over it on guitar
- The B minor pentatonic. B, D, E, F♯, A, with the root on the 6th string, 7th fret. It works over Bm7, Em7 and Gmaj7. Over F♯7, its A natural rubs against the chord's third, A♯: play it as a blue note, or replace it.
- G, the missing note. The pentatonic has no G, yet G is the third of Em7 and the root of Gmaj7. Add it in those bars (the fifth, sixth and ninth). Add C♯ as well and you get B natural minor (B, C♯, D, E, F♯, G, A), the scale for the whole tune except F♯7.
- The F♯7 → Bm7 resolution. Over F♯7, use B harmonic minor (with A♯) and aim for A♯: it moves up a half step to B in bar 11.
- All the chords in one zone. Bm7 with the root on the 6th string, 7th fret; Em7, F♯7 and Gmaj7 with the root on the 5th string, at the 7th, 9th and 10th frets. When comping, play short chords and few notes: at this tempo, space matters as much as sound.
The versions that matter
- Roy Hawkins — Modern Records single, 1951: the original, in the dark style that won over Bob Geddins, No. 6 on the R&B chart.
- B.B. King — Completely Well (BluesWay), 1969: the definitive version, with strings arranged by Bert DeCoteaux and the dialogue between the voice and Lucille.
- Aretha Franklin — Spirit in the Dark, 1970: a soul reading, released the same year as King's hit.
- B.B. King — Live in Cook County Jail, 1971: recorded in September 1970 in front of the inmates of a Chicago jail, the song passes the stage test a year after its success.
- Bobby Bland and B.B. King — Together Again… Live, 1976: two blues giants sharing the song in concert.
- B.B. King and Tracy Chapman — Deuces Wild, 1997: a duet that hands the song to a new generation.
Sources
- The Thrill Is Gone — Wikipedia EN — Hawkins and Darnell 1951, slow minor-key blues, No. 6 on the R&B chart, Completely Well, Szymczyk (his first hit), BluesWay single of December 1969, No. 3 R&B and No. 15 Hot 100, Grammy for 1970 (13th ceremony), Grammy Hall of Fame 1998, Rolling Stone No. 183, Aretha Franklin, live versions (Cook County Jail, Together Again).
- The Thrill Is Gone — Wikipedia FR (in French) — writers and date, 3:55 single, list of covers (Aretha Franklin 1970).
- Roy Hawkins — Wikipedia EN — born in Jefferson, Texas, in 1903, Oakland, Bob Geddins, Modern 1949-1954, accident and paralyzed arm, Why Do Everything Happen to Me (No. 2 R&B in 1950), session players including Maxwell Davis, credit shared with Jules Bihari, left Modern in 1954, last recordings in 1961.
- The Thrill Is Gone (Roy Hawkins CD) — Ace Records — Geddins discovers Hawkins, accident and paralyzed arm, Maxwell Davis producing, replacement pianist, No. 6 R&B in July 1951, King's cover on BluesWay.
- Classic Tracks: B.B. King's "The Thrill Is Gone" — Mix — 1969 New York session, last song of the last session, personnel, Lucille (Gibson), keeper on the third try, live vocal, Bert DeCoteaux strings recorded a week later, Szymczyk quote.
- Blues Hall of Fame: The Thrill Is Gone — Blues Foundation — recorded in New York in 1969, personnel, DeCoteaux strings, shortened single, chart entry on December 27, 1969, No. 3 R&B and No. 15 Hot 100, King's highest pop chart position, successive songwriting credits.
- The Thrill Is Gone — Songs with Earlier Histories — No. 6 R&B for Hawkins, King as a Memphis disc jockey discovering the original, Szymczyk's idea for strings, Grammy, Grammy Hall of Fame, Rolling Stone, Live in Cook County Jail (September 10, 1970).
- The Thrill Is Gone — Songfacts — King as a Memphis DJ playing the original, subject of the song, Szymczyk's late-night call, Szymczyk as the Eagles' producer, live version with Bobby Bland, duet with Tracy Chapman.
- Deuces Wild — Wikipedia EN — 1997, duet with Tracy Chapman.