A music with no birth certificate
The blues was born in the American South, among African Americans, probably around 1890. It grew out of work songs, spirituals and rural music. Exactly why it emerged is still poorly understood, and a music passed on by word of mouth left almost no written trace.
Charles Peabody noted songs of this kind in Clarksdale, Mississippi, around 1901-1902. Ma Rainey, the future "Mother of the Blues," would say she discovered it around 1902. And around 1903, at the Tutwiler train station in the Delta, a bandleader named W. C. Handy was waiting for a train. A man was singing while pressing a knife blade against his guitar strings, like a bottleneck. In his autobiography, Father of the Blues (1941), Handy calls it "the weirdest music" he had ever heard.
There was no single set of changes yet: the songs Howard Odum collected between 1905 and 1908 have verses of varying length.
1912: the blues goes to the printer
In 1912, three pieces of sheet music with "blues" in the title were published. In March, Hart A. Wand published "Dallas Blues" in Oklahoma City. In August, in St. Louis, the African American vaudeville pianist H. Franklin "Baby" Seals published "Baby Seals Blues." In September, Handy had "The Memphis Blues" printed at his own expense.
The title of "first" is still disputed. "Dallas Blues" is often presented as the first copyrighted blues, but Anthony Maggio's "I Got the Blues" already followed a twelve-bar structure in 1908. Historian Samuel Charters, who considered "Dallas Blues" the first published piece in the Black blues idiom, pointed out the irony: it was written by a white man.
Handy, for his part, let "Memphis Blues" go for a hundred dollars in all: according to Charters, fifty for the rights and the plates, and fifty for a thousand unsold copies. He made up for it in 1914 with "St. Louis Blues," one of the first blues to succeed as a popular song. Its verses follow the twelve-bar form and the AAB pattern: a four-bar line, its repetition over the next four bars, then an answer.
1920: the record that opens a market
On August 10, 1920, Mamie Smith recorded "Crazy Blues" for Okeh, with her Jazz Hounds. The song was by Perry Bradford, who had pushed the label to record a Black singer. According to NPR, it all started by chance earlier that year: Sophie Tucker, booked for a session, had fallen ill, and Mamie Smith had replaced her.
Is it the first recorded blues? No. "Memphis Blues" was on record as early as 1914, and the blues cut before 1920 were mostly by white artists, for white audiences. "Crazy Blues," however, was the first big blues hit sung by an African American artist: 75,000 copies in a month, according to NPR. Record companies discovered a neglected audience and launched their "race records" series. In the 1920s and 1930s, with Bessie Smith and Ma Rainey, the twelve-bar form became widespread.
It settled gradually. In early versions, the tenth bar often stayed on the dominant (V-V-I); moving through the IV (V-IV-I) became the norm later. Another very common variation is the "quick change": you go to the IV chord in the second bar before returning to the I.
From the Delta to Chicago
On June 14, 1929, in Richmond, Indiana, Charley Patton recorded for Paramount. He sometimes played guitar behind his back. Many consider him the father of the Delta blues: a stripped-down style, intense singing, often slide guitar.
Robert Johnson left only 29 songs, cut in San Antonio in November 1936 and in Dallas in June 1937. He died in 1938, at 27, of unknown causes. Legend has it that he sold his soul to the devil at a crossroads. The story was first told about another bluesman, Tommy Johnson, no relation; writers later attached it to Robert. His boogie bass line on guitar would be picked up by Chuck Berry.
Then came the Great Migration to the cities of the North. In August 1941, Alan Lomax recorded Muddy Waters at his home in Stovall for the Library of Congress. After settling in Chicago in 1943, Waters switched to electric guitar the following year: an acoustic could no longer be heard over the noise of the clubs. In 1948, "I Can't Be Satisfied" came out on Aristocrat, soon renamed Chess. Chicago became the center of electric blues.
Jazz musicians rewrite the changes
Bebop turned the form into a laboratory. On November 26, 1945, Charlie Parker recorded "Now's the Time" with a young Miles Davis. Jazz musicians added seventh chords and, above all, ii-V progressions: a minor chord that sets up the dominant. In August 1951, Parker went further with "Blues for Alice." The first chord becomes a major seventh, then a cascade of descending ii-Vs leads to the IV chord in bar 5. These changes have been called "Bird blues" ever since, after Parker's nickname.
The blues also comes in minor. In May 1959, John Coltrane recorded "Mr. P.C." In this type of blues, the V chord can be major or minor.
From rhythm and blues to rock 'n' roll
On August 13, 1952, Big Mama Thornton recorded "Hound Dog," written the day before by Jerry Leiber and Mike Stoller. It is a twelve-bar blues, but her phrasing stretches some choruses to thirteen. In February 1954, Big Joe Turner cut "Shake, Rattle and Roll," which Bill Haley covered by June. In 1956, Elvis Presley's version of "Hound Dog" topped the pop, country and R&B charts at the same time. Rock 'n' roll has often been described as blues with a "backbeat," the accents hit on beats two and four.
The changes, and their variations
The twelve-bar blues rests on three chords, those on degrees I, IV and V of the key: in A, that means A7, D7 and E7. The twelve bars divide into three four-bar phrases, and the last bars (the "turnaround") kick off the next chorus. On that foundation, every era has added its own variations.
The quick change moves to the IV chord in the second bar, then back to the I. It is very common in electric blues.
The jazz blues keeps the frame and adds ii-Vs: a move toward the IV in bar 4, a passing diminished chord, then a ii-V ending.
The minor blues replaces the seventh chords with minor chords and often goes through the chord built on the flatted sixth degree (F7 in A minor, written ♭VI7) before the dominant.
What to play over it on guitar
- The minor pentatonic of the key, then the blues scale (with the flatted fifth): that is the basic vocabulary of all blues.
- Follow the chords. Over A7, aim for C♯ (the third); over D7, aim for F♯; over E7, aim for G♯. Mixing those thirds with the pentatonic is the sound of B.B. King as much as it is the sound of jazz.
- Your picking hand. Before the solo, the shuffle: chords in swung eighth notes, with the bass pattern alternating the fifth and the sixth under each chord.
- All twelve keys. The blues gets played in every key: E and A for guitarists, F and B♭ for horn players. Change keys as soon as you have the changes down.
The songs that matter
- Mamie Smith and Her Jazz Hounds — Crazy Blues, 1920: the hit that proved to record companies that an African American audience was waiting for its own blues.
- Bessie Smith (with Louis Armstrong on cornet) — St. Louis Blues, 1925: Handy's classic, with twelve-bar verses, inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1993.
- Robert Johnson — Sweet Home Chicago, 1936: recorded in San Antonio, later a blues standard.
- Charlie Parker — Now's the Time, 1945: a riff blues that brought the form into bebop.
- Muddy Waters — I Can't Be Satisfied, 1948: the hit that marks Chicago's rise as the center of electric blues.
- Charlie Parker — Blues for Alice, 1951: the model for "Bird blues," with its chains of ii-Vs.
- Big Mama Thornton — Hound Dog, 1952 (released in 1953): a blues that rock 'n' roll would make its own.
- John Coltrane — Mr. P.C., 1959: a twelve-bar minor blues, a tribute to bassist Paul Chambers, released on the album Giant Steps.
Sources
- Twelve-bar blues — Wikipedia — I-IV-V chords, repeated dominant in bar 12, then V-IV-I-I, definition of the quick change, jazz ii-Vs, minor blues (major or minor V), Coltrane examples.
- Blues — Wikipedia — origins around 1890, causes poorly understood, Peabody (Clarksdale, 1901-1902), accounts from 1902-1903, Odum 1905-1908, three pieces of 1912 sheet music, AAB and Handy's explanation, twelve bars becoming widespread in the 1920s-1930s, Delta blues, the Great Migration, "I Can't Be Satisfied," bebop, "blues with a backbeat," "Hound Dog" as a twelve-bar blues.
- Blues — Wikipedia (in French) — cross-check: born in the South in the late 19th century, Mamie Smith 1920 as the first commercially released African American blues record, twelve bars as the most common form, Parker and "Blues for Alice."
- W. C. Handy — Wikipedia — Tutwiler 1903, guitar played with a knife, 1941 autobiography, publication of "Memphis Blues" in 1912, "St. Louis Blues" 1914.
- Historical marker "W. C. Handy Encounters the Blues" — HMDB — text of the Mississippi Blues Trail marker: Tutwiler station around 1903, a date Handy never specified, quote about the "weirdest music," source Father of the Blues.
- W.C. Handy's Mississippi experiences earn Blues Trail marker — SuperTalk Mississippi — cross-check of the Tutwiler episode and the quote; date of the Cleveland evening (1905).
- The Memphis Blues — Wikipedia — self-published in September 1912, rights and plates sold for 50 dollars, plus 50 for unsold copies (Charters), 100 dollars in all, success after the 1914 Victor and Columbia recordings, alternating 12- and 16-bar sections.
- Dallas Blues — Wikipedia — Hart A. Wand, March 1912, Oklahoma City; Maggio's "I Got the Blues" (1908); Charters's remark about the white author.
- Baby Seals Blues — Wikipedia — H. Franklin "Baby" Seals, vaudeville pianist, published August 1912 in St. Louis, a few months before "Memphis Blues."
- St. Louis Blues (song) — Wikipedia — published September 1914, three-line twelve-bar verses, pop success, Bessie Smith's 1925 recording with Louis Armstrong.
- Crazy Blues — Wikipedia — August 10, 1920, Okeh, Perry Bradford, 75,000 copies in two months (Gioia), debate over the "first."
- Mamie Smith — Wikipedia — February 1920 session, Bradford's role, figure of a million in under a year (not used).
- Mamie Smith And The Birth Of The Blues Market — NPR — the Sophie Tucker illness anecdote, 10,000 copies the first week, 75,000 in a month, race records.
- Crazy Blues — Blues Foundation (Blues Hall of Fame) — Smith was not the first to sing blues on record, earlier blues being mostly by white artists; sales estimates from 10,000 to 2 million; birth of the race records series.
- Aug. 10, 1920 — Mississippi Today — context (Red Summer); figure of more than 2 million (not used).
- Standardizing the Blues — Smithsonian Folkways — "Memphis Blues" (1912) as a semi-standardized basis, "Crazy Blues" (1920) and the blues becoming marketable.
- Ma Rainey — Wikipedia — discovered the blues around 1902 by her own account, nickname "Mother of the Blues," first records in December 1923.
- Charley Patton — Wikipedia — Dockery plantation, Paramount session of June 14, 1929, in Richmond (Indiana), guitar behind the back, "Father of the Delta Blues."
- Robert Johnson — Wikipedia — San Antonio (1936) and Dallas (1937) sessions, 29 songs, death in 1938, crossroads legend first tied to Tommy Johnson, boogie bass picked up by Chuck Berry, "Sweet Home Chicago" recorded in 1936.
- Muddy Waters — Wikipedia — Lomax at Stovall in August 1941, Chicago 1943, electric guitar 1944, Aristocrat becoming Chess, "I Can't Be Satisfied" 1948, "Rollin' Stone" 1950.
- Now's the Time (composition) — Wikipedia — recorded November 26, 1945, with Miles Davis, riff blues.
- Blues for Alice — Wikipedia — August 1951, Verve, modified twelve-bar blues in F, heavy use of the ii-V-I, example of "Bird blues."
- Bird changes — Wikipedia — definition of Bird blues: a chain of ii-Vs leading to the IV chord, named after Parker's nickname.
- Beyond Blues: How to Play Bird Blues — Premier Guitar — first chord a major seventh, descending ii-Vs toward bar 5, minor ii in bar 9.
- Mr. P.C. — Wikipedia — May 1959, album Giant Steps, tribute to Paul Chambers, twelve-bar minor blues.
- Hound Dog (song) — Wikipedia — Thornton, August 13, 1952, written the day before by Leiber and Stoller, twelve bars with thirteen-bar choruses, released in 1953, seven weeks at No. 1 R&B; Elvis 1956 topping all three charts.
- Shake, Rattle and Roll — Wikipedia — Big Joe Turner, February 15, 1954, Atlantic; Bill Haley's cover recorded June 7, 1954.
- Johnny B. Goode — Wikipedia — consulted for Chuck Berry (released 1958, Chess); not used in the text for lack of a source confirming the form.